User:ConnorPrim/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Amazing Grace

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I love this hymn, and it has been incredibly important to my life over the years.

Lead Section
Very effective lead section. Tells exactly what the hymn is, when it was written, and who composed it. The next sentence also introduces why it is important enough to have a Wikipedia pages.

Content
The information is thorough, relevant, up-to-date, and covers all the important aspects of the tune.

Tone and Balance
This article isn't necessarily a very controversial one, but it does include both secular and religious viewpoints. Neither seems to be overly emphasized, so this allows for a neutral voice even when speaking on a religious song.

Sources and References
There are 24 different sources, with 99 total citations. I would say this article has been highly researched, and the sources reflect a wide variety of different authors and viewpoints.

Organization and Writing Quality
There are a myriad of different headings and sections that allow for easy understanding of each main point. This allows a reader to understand more about the song just by a glance, which is an incredibly powerful thing.

Images and Media
If there's one issue with the article, it's that there are very few images included. There is so much text that it can seem daunting to read it all, and some more pictures could have helped break up this monotony. The images included, however, do fit the Wikipedia guidelines very well though.

Talk Page Discussion
As a featured article, it hasn't been significantly changed since 2012. However, back then there was a bit of a heated argument between someone who went in and changed a few things and the original author of the article. That was quite entertaining to read :)

Overall Impressions
Overall, this is a very strong article. It is featured for a reason, and it has the sources and citations to back it up. I have no significant feedback, but it was a great experience to look at this critically and try to figure out what made it such a strong article.