User:Cotviola/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Stage combat

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article to evaluate because I have an interest in the topic. My first impression of the article was that it provided sound information.

Evaluate the article
Lead Section

The lead section started with a strong opening sentence. The section didn't exactly highlight what the following sections would be, but it was concise and provided good background information.

Content

The article had content that was relevant to the topic. the content was up to date, but there was some missing content in sections about Asian fight combat. Not much was written that dealt with equality gaps.

Evaluating tone

The tone of the article was neutral and seemed to not rely heavily on bias although, there is a heavier focus on European fight combat, and in fact it is noted on the article that the section on Asian fight combat needs to be expanded.

Evaluating sources

The links that are referenced work well, but a lot of the citations are not very reliable. A lot of the sources are biased and unverified.

Talk Page

Some of the conversations going on behind the scenes seem to highlight some of the issues that I noticed about the article regarding the content and sources. The article is rated "start class" or "C class." It is a Wiki education foundation-supported course assignment. The discussion was not conducted in an unexpected way.