User:CrazyC83/CanadaCities

Here is my opinion on each of them:

British Columbia

 * North Vancouver - OK to move
 * Port Alberni - OK to move

Alberta

 * Grande Prairie - change to dab page covering both spellings of Grand Prairie and Grande Prairie

Disambiguation pages to review: Spruce Grove. - undo move, keep as dab

Saskatchewan

 * Battleford - OK to move
 * Swift Current - OK to move

Manitoba

 * Carberry - Convert to dab page Done
 * Gilbert Plains - OK to move
 * Hamiota - OK to move
 * Hartney - OK to move
 * Lynn Lake - Leave alone, possible lakes with that name warranting articles?
 * Neepawa - OK to move
 * The Pas - OK to move
 * Pinawa - OK to move
 * Ste. Rose du Lac - Might be other places with that name?
 * Winnipeg Beach - Does the beach itself warrant an article separate from the municipality? Needs review

Red links:
 * Leaf Rapids - OK to move
 * Minitonas - OK to move
 * Plum Coulee - Needs review, is there an actual coulee with the name?
 * Powerview-Pine Falls - OK to move
 * Rossburn - OK to move
 * Teulon - OK to move
 * Treherne - OK to move

Disambiguation pages to review: Lac du Bonnet - leave alone, Minnedosa - leave alone.

Ontario
Status: All cities, towns and villages with plain name redirects are listed here or have already been resolved; townships completed only through C. Some former towns have been listed as well, but not comprehensively.
 * Addington Highlands - Do the highlands warrant an article separate from the municipality? Needs review
 * Adjala-Tosorontio - OK to move
 * Alfred and Plantagenet - OK to move
 * Alnwick/Haldimand - OK to move
 * Amherstburg - OK to move
 * Arran-Elderslie - OK to move
 * Ashfield-Colborne-Wawanosh - OK to move
 * Bracebridge - OK to move
 * Bradford West Gwillimbury - OK to move
 * Brantford - OK to move
 * Burk's Falls - Do the falls themselves warrant an article separate from the municipality? Needs review
 * Capreol - OK to move, at least for the community
 * Carleton Place - Leave alone, could be conflicts with "Carlton Place", if other articles are created, make a dab page
 * Central Elgin - Leave alone, easy to be confused with non-technical geography
 * Clarence-Rockland - OK to move
 * Clarington - OK to move
 * Cobourg - OK to move
 * Deseronto - Dab page with John Deseronto? Otherwise OK to move
 * Englehart - OK to move
 * Fort Frances - Is there an actual fort with the name? Needs review
 * Gananoque - OK to move
 * Greater Napanee - OK to move
 * Haldimand County - Leave alone for now (anything ending in County can be easily confused with stuff elsewhere, even if not unique), check other regions' standards.
 * Halton Hills - OK to move, unless the hills themselves warrant an article
 * Hilton Beach - Does the beach itself warrant an article separate from the municipality? Needs review
 * Ingersoll - Move onto Ingersoll (disambiguation), I don't think it is the most important topic Approved
 * Innisfil - Redirect to Innisfail as combined dab page Approved
 * Iroquois Falls - Do the falls themselves warrant an article separate from the municipality? Needs review
 * Kapuskasing - OK to move
 * Kirkland Lake - Leave alone, possible lakes with that name warranting articles?
 * Doubtful. I literally had to funnel a Google search all the way down to "Kirkland Lake" -Ontario -ON -CJKL -Virginiatown -Dobie -Kearns -Kenogami -"Northern College" -Gold -Enouy -garbage -"Adams Mine" -"Highway 66" -Temagami -Timiskaming -"New Liskeard" -Haileybury -Teck just to find even one page that didn't pertain to the Ontario town — and even that page didn't turn out to be about a "Kirkland Lake", but about a town called Kirkland that's located on the shore of a Lake Washington. Bearcat (talk) 04:06, 28 November 2008 (UTC)
 * Then OK to move. CrazyC83 (talk) 04:24, 28 November 2008 (UTC)


 * Markstay-Warren - OK to move
 * Mississippi Mills - Needs review, name somewhat deceptive (suggesting Mills of Mississippi?)
 * Moosonee - OK to move
 * New Tecumseth - OK to move
 * Nickel Centre - OK to move
 * Northeastern Manitoulin and the Islands - OK to move
 * Oil Springs - Perhaps actual springs elsewhere possibly warranting? Leave alone for now
 * Onaping Falls - OK to move, at least for the community
 * Penetanguishene - OK to move
 * Petawawa - Dab page between municipality and CFB, since they seem to be quite conflicting
 * Port Colborne - OK to move
 * Port Hope - Dab page with Port Hope, Michigan and others?
 * Powassan - Leave alone, possible dab between old community and municipality?
 * Is there any realistic likelihood of us ever actually needing separate articles about those two topics, rather than just one? Bearcat (talk) 04:08, 28 November 2008 (UTC)
 * Not likely, but not impossible. Category:Former cities has dozens of entries. CrazyC83 (talk) 04:24, 28 November 2008 (UTC)


 * Quinte West - OK to move
 * Rayside-Balfour - OK to move
 * Saugeen Shores - OK to move
 * Sioux Lookout - OK to move
 * Smiths Falls - Do the falls themselves warrant an article separate from the municipality? Needs review
 * Smooth Rock Falls - Do the falls themselves warrant an article separate from the municipality? Needs review
 * South Bruce Peninsula - Leave alone, easy to be confused with non-technical geography
 * Temagami - Leave alone, possible dab between lake, old community and municipality?
 * Temiskaming Shores - OK to move
 * Thorold - Needs review, due to former municipalities and individuals connected
 * Tillsonburg - OK to move
 * Trent Hills - OK to move, unless the hills themselves warrant an article
 * Valley East - Redirect to East Valley
 * Wasaga Beach - Dab with Wasaga Beach Provincial Park
 * West Nipissing - Leave alone, easy to be confused with non-technical geography

Red links:
 * Adelaide-Metcalfe - OK to move
 * Admaston Bromley - OK to move
 * Algonquin Highlands - Needs review, are there actual highlands with the name?
 * Asphodel-Norwood - OK to move
 * Assiginack - OK to move
 * Barrie Island - Primary topic should be island itself, leave alone unless they are completely identical
 * Black River-Matheson - OK to move
 * Blandford-Blenheim - OK to move
 * Bonnechere Valley - Redirect to Bonnechere River
 * Brethour - OK to move
 * Brooke-Alvinston - OK to move
 * Bruce Mines - Needs review, are there actual mines with the name?
 * Brudenell, Lyndoch and Raglan - OK to move
 * Burpee and Mills - OK to move
 * Carlow/Mayo - OK to move
 * Central Frontenac - Leave alone, easy to confuse with general geography
 * Central Manitoulin - Leave alone, easy to confuse with general geography
 * Centre Hastings - Leave alone, easy to confuse with general geography
 * Charlton and Dack - OK to move
 * Conmee - OK to move
 * Cramahe - OK to move
 * Gore Bay - Needs review, is there an actual bay with the name?
 * Laurentian Hills - Redirect to Laurentian Mountains
 * Merrickville-Wolford - OK to move
 * Plympton-Wyoming - Leave alone, easy to perceive as Plympton, Wyoming (even though I don't know if such a place exists)
 * Point Edward - Needs review, is there an actual point with the name?
 * South Huron - Leave alone, easy to confuse with general geography
 * Thornloe - OK to move
 * Wanup - OK to move

Disambiguation pages to review: Chapleau, Kitchener, Parry Sound, Sarnia. - Leave all alone

Question for deliberation: Could Fort Erie be moved to Fort Erie National Historic Site, and Fort Erie, Ontario to Fort Erie? - Leave alone

Quebec
Status: Only villes have been listed or resolved to date.
 * Acton Vale - OK to move
 * L'Ancienne-Lorette - OK to move
 * L'Assomption - Redirect to Assumption (disambiguation)
 * Baie-Comeau - OK to move
 * Baie-Saint-Paul - Is there an actual bay with the name? Otherwise OK to move
 * Baie-d'Urfé - OK to move
 * Beauceville - OK to move
 * Bécancour - Move onto Bécancour (disambiguation), since the city isn't that much more notable
 * Berthierville - OK to move
 * Boisbriand - OK to move
 * Boucherville - OK to move
 * Bromont - OK to move
 * Cabano - OK to move
 * Cap-Chat - Is there an actual cape with the name? Otherwise OK to move
 * Chibougamau - OK to move
 * Coaticook - OK to move
 * Côte Saint-Luc - Is there an actual coast with the name? Otherwise OK to move
 * Cowansville - OK to move
 * Deux-Montagnes - Redirect to Deux Montagnes
 * Dolbeau-Mistassini - OK to move
 * Dollard-des-Ormeaux - OK to move
 * Dorval - Dab page with Dorval Airport
 * Joliette - Dab with Joliette Regional County Municipality, Quebec
 * Kingsey Falls - Do the falls themselves warrant an article separate from the municipality? Needs review
 * Kuujjuaq - OK to move
 * L'Épiphanie - Redirect to Epiphany (disambiguation)
 * Lachute - OK to move
 * Lévis - Redirect to Levis, as few will be typing with the accent
 * Louiseville - Redirect to Louisville (disambiguation), easy to confuse
 * Agreed (the one in Quebec has a population of 7,400, so I'm not certain that its notability actually exceeds the possibility of this being a typo for Louisville), though a number of direct links should be fixed before this is actually changed. Bearcat (talk) 04:17, 28 November 2008 (UTC)


 * La Malbaie - OK to move
 * Maniwaki - OK to move
 * Mascouche - OK to move
 * Mont-Joli - Leave alone, possible mountain with that name warranting articles?
 * Mont-Laurier - Leave alone, possible mountain with that name warranting articles?
 * Mont-Saint-Hilaire - Leave alone, possible mountain with that name warranting articles?
 * Mont-Tremblant - Move onto Mont-Tremblant (disambiguation), often confused with the resort, park, mountain, etc.
 * Montreal West - OK to move
 * Montréal-Est - OK to move
 * Nicolet - Redirect to Nicolette, easy to confuse
 * Percé - Dab with Rocher Perce
 * Pohénégamook - OK to move
 * Pointe-Claire - OK to move
 * Rosemère - OK to move
 * Saint-Augustin-de-Desmaures - OK to move
 * Saint-Hyacinthe - Create Saint Hyacinth (disambiguation)
 * Saint-Jean-sur-Richelieu - OK to move
 * Saint-Jérôme - Redirect to Saint Jerome (disambiguation)
 * Saint-Lazare - Leave alone, seems to be other uses
 * Saint-Raymond - Redirect to Saint Raymond
 * Sainte-Agathe-des-Monts - OK to move
 * Sainte-Anne-de-Beaupré - OK to move
 * Sainte-Anne-de-Bellevue - OK to move
 * Sainte-Anne-des-Plaines - OK to move
 * Sainte-Thérèse - Redirect to Saint Teresa
 * Salaberry-de-Valleyfield - OK to move
 * La Sarre - OK to move
 * Schefferville - OK to move
 * Senneterre - OK to move
 * Sorel-Tracy - OK to move
 * La Tuque - OK to move
 * Valcourt - OK to move
 * Vaudreuil-Dorion - OK to move
 * Victoriaville - OK to move
 * Westmount - Move onto Westmount (disambiguation), others seem to be quite notable

New Brunswick

 * Edmundston - OK to move
 * Grand Bay-Westfield - OK to move
 * Lamèque - OK to move
 * Nigadoo - OK to move
 * Shippagan - OK to move
 * Tracadie-Sheila - OK to move

Newfoundland and Labrador
Status: Only cities have been dealt with to date.

Northwest Territories
Status: All settlements listed here or resolved.
 * Aklavik - OK to move
 * Behchoko - OK to move
 * Cape Dorset - Is there an actual cape with the name? Needs review
 * Deline - OK to move
 * Dettah - OK to move
 * Fort Good Hope - Is there an actual fort with the name? Needs review
 * Fort Liard - Is there an actual fort with the name? Needs review
 * Fort Providence - Is there an actual fort with the name? Needs review
 * Fort Resolution - Is there an actual fort with the name? Needs review
 * Fort Simpson - Is there an actual fort with the name? Needs review
 * Gamètì - OK to move
 * Inuvik - OK to move
 * Jean Marie River - Is there an actual river with the name? Needs review
 * Lutselk'e - OK to move
 * Nahanni Butte - Is there an actual butte with the name? Needs review
 * N'Dilo - OK to move
 * Norman Wells - OK to move
 * Paulatuk - OK to move
 * Pine Point - OK to move
 * Port Radium - OK to move
 * Sachs Harbour - OK to move
 * Tsiigehtchic - OK to move
 * Ulukhaktok - OK to move
 * Wekweeti - OK to move
 * Whati - OK to move

Red links:
 * Kakisa - OK to move
 * Old Fort Providence - Needs review, is there an actual fort with the name?

Dab pages for review: Baker Lake, Colville Lake, Tulita. - The lakes themselves (not the cities) should get the primary article. Leave Tulita alone.

Nunavut
Status: All settlements listed here or resolved.
 * Arctic Bay - Is there an actual bay with the name? Needs review
 * Arviat - OK to move
 * Cambridge Bay - Is there an actual bay with the name? Needs review
 * Chesterfield Inlet - Is there an actual inlet with the name? Needs review
 * Coral Harbour - OK to move
 * Gjoa Haven - OK to move
 * Grise Fiord - Is there an actual fjord with the name? Needs review
 * Hall Beach - Is there an actual beach with the name? Needs review
 * Igloolik - OK to move
 * Isachsen - OK to move
 * Kimmirut - OK to move
 * Kugaaruk - OK to move
 * Nanisivik - OK to move
 * Pangnirtung - OK to move
 * Pond Inlet - Is there an actual inlet with the name? Needs review
 * Rankin Inlet - Is there an actual inlet with the name? Needs review
 * Sanikiluaq - OK to move
 * Taloyoak - OK to move

Red links:
 * Qikiqtarjuaq - OK to move
 * Umingmaktok - OK to move

Dab pages for review: Kugluktuk. No longer a dab page, OK to move.

Yukon
Status: All settlements listed here or resolved.


 * Burwash Landing - OK to move
 * Carcross - OK to move
 * Carmacks - Redirect to Carmack, easy to confuse - Done.
 * Fort Selkirk - Is there an actual fort with the name? Needs review
 * Haines Junction - OK to move

Red links:
 * Aishihik - OK to move
 * Army Beach - Is there an actual beach with the name? Needs review
 * Clinton Creek - Is there an actual creek with the name? Needs review
 * Destruction Bay - Is there an actual bay with the name? Needs review
 * Keno City - OK to move
 * Mount Lorne - Is there an actual mountain with the name? Needs review
 * Pelly Crossing - OK to move
 * Upper Liard - Needs review, might be confused with the upper Liard Highway

Discussion: Ibex Valley is a two-line unreferenced stub which does little besides point people to the municipality of Ibex Valley, Yukon. Should it be expanded into a proper article about the valley itself, or just merged with the municipality? - Not sure.