User:Daniellesori/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Lumad

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because it directly relates to the advocacy work my PE organization engages in. It matters because the social issues that the Indigenous peoples of the Philippines undergo are a dense issue/social structure that Liyang Network attempt to learn and educate others on.

Evaluate the article
Evaluating content


 * Everything in the article is relevant to its topic. Looking over the history of the Lumad article, it has been revised pretty frequently and kept up to date. I am interested in including a section on the advocacy work that is being done to address the social issues Lumad experience.

Evaluating tone


 * I believe the section on Lumad social issues is expressed as neutral as possible. Majority of the sentences are factual, however, it's a bit difficult to present an unbiased point of view of the Lumad against government officials and militarization.

Evaluating sources


 * The links work for the sources and are all reliable. Majority of these citations are from authors from the Republic of the Philippines. Looking over the cited writers, I can assume almost all of the last names are of people of color, suggesting a diverse array of authors. The publications sound reliable as they range from the years 1940 until 2021.

Checking the talk page


 * Conversations in the talk page discuss the possible inclusion of including tribes, mining facilities on Lumad land, and even pictures to consider. The article is rated B-Class and within the scope of WikiProject Ethnic groups.