User:Dawid2009/nomination to VA

Remove

 * Support
 * 1) As nom
 * Oppose


 * Discuss

Add

 * Support
 * 1) As nom
 * Oppose

Swap for

 * Support
 * 1) As nom


 * Oppose

--

Remove Eusebio, Mia Hamm, Lev Yashin
Currently we have one player from USA woman national team and too many man soccer players from 60's who never won FIFA world cup. England man National soccer team is more vital than USA woman national team |England_national_football_team and this team has won fifa world cup one time in history and just in 1966. This list has to be important for reeaders for English Wikipedia not for worldwide view. So it is insulting for anyone from United Kingtom when we include Eusebio, Mia Hamm, Lev Yashin above: Bobby Charlton, Bobby More (they won world cup in 1966 with England) and George Best (He played for North Irleand but he has been regarted as the best sport personality of the century by BBC among people such like Mohhamad Ali, etc. and he still has enaugh reputation). If we do not have any hockey goalkeepers at this level I really do not think that we need Lev Yashin here. Mia Hamm often is compared to Aby Wambach and Alex Morgan so she is not very greatest woman of all time. Eusebio at his best peak in my oinion was much better player than Michel Platini or Cristiano Ronaldo at their best peak but I would left Platini ahead Eusebio due to fact that he was long time UEFFA president and I would left Cristiano Ronaldo ahead Eusebio due to fact that he won 2016 UE with Portugal and Eusebio not.
 * Support
 * 1) As nom
 * Oppose


 * Discuss

Add Sepp Blatter
Soccer, American football, Baseball and Basketgball are four sports where coach/bussiness person is enaugh popular and focussed for inclusion here. Sepp Blatter among eight president of FIFA is the most vital person because of he even has his own category. He is the only reasonable choice to include here among soccer bussiness personalities. Alex Ferguson will never be listed at this level because of he even is not the most important Scottish soccer personality (Kenny Daglish is more vital. It is not accident that exist Kenny Dalglish Soccer Manager or Kenny Dalglish Soccer Match but not Ferguson Manager). If we are going to make diversity list in my opinion in my opinion one bussiness personality is better choice than one woman player. Generally Bussiness personalities/coaches always have more wikidata entires than woman soccer players on Wikipedia and often even if they were born in 19th century. Jules Rimet have 53 wikidta entires despite fact he was born in 19th centry, Vittorio Pozzo was born in 19th centoury too and he has 33 etc.
 * Support
 * 1) As nom
 * Oppose


 * Discuss

remove Roger Bannister and Hicham El Guerrouj
14 athletics it is too many at this level if we cover only athlets from last 100 years.
 * Support
 * 1) As nom
 * Oppose


 * Discuss

remove Luciana Aymar
Currently we have two field hockey players at the level 4 and one futsal player at the level 5. It is not proportional because of futsal is more popular sport than field hockey despite fact futsal is not olympic sport. I agree that we do not need any futsal players at this level but I will never agree that number of field hockey players at the level 5 should be higher than number of futsal players at the level 5
 * Support
 * 1) As nom
 * Oppose


 * Discuss

Add Junko Tabei
She was the first woman to reach the summit of Mount Everest, and the first woman to ascend all Seven Summits by climbing the highest peak on every continent.
 * Support
 * 1) As nom
 * Oppose


 * Discuss

Add Branch Rickey
Soccer, American football, Baseball and Basketgball are four sports where coach/bussiness person is enaugh focussed for inclusion here. In my opinion Branch Rickey deserve to be swapped for one Baseball player. It is the only bussiness personality ratedd as top-importance article by relevant wikiproject. At this level we have poople who have worse importance scale
 * Support
 * 1) As nom
 * Oppose


 * Discuss