User:Ddelyser/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Flag of Antarctica - Wikipedia

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose the flag of Antarctica because it is a niche topic that few people think about, which gives me the opportunity to potentially add to it. In the future, there may become a time when people try to create their own country on Antarctica, and if that ever happen, many people may become interested in the history of its flag and be inspired by versions of it to create their own.

Evaluate the article
LEAD SECTION

The lead section is very short, with one short paragraph and one sentence after that. The first sentence does a good job of quickly telling you what the flag of Antarctica is.

CONTENT

The content is relative to the topic and was updated just over a month ago. On certain flags such as the True South Proposal, there is not enough detail on the origins of the flag.

TONE AND BALANCE

The article has no bias and has a neutral tone.

SOURCES AND REFERENCES

There is a large variety of sources that provide different information

ORGANIZATION AND WRITING QUALITY

There are a handful of grammatical issues, however, the writing is overall professional, easy to read, and well-organized.

IMAGES AND MEDIA

There are images for each of the flags discussed.

TALK PAGE

There is discussion regarding information on each of the types of flags. The last discussion was April of 2023. The Article is C rated.

OVERALL IMPRESSIONS

The article is clear, concise, and well- organized. However, there is a lot of content that could be added, such as providing more background on where certain flags came from.