User:Deep sea coral/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list article

Option 1

 * Article Title
 * Melanie Smith (equestrian)
 * Article Evaluation
 * This article is very short and doesn't include any pictures of Melanie Smith or Calypso, the horse she won the Olympics with. It also needs to talk more about her life, and how she now trains horses on her farm in Germantown, TN, just outside of Memphis, TN. It also needs to mention her other awards, such as winning the Show Jumping Triple Crown and being included in the TN Sports Hall of Fame. One of the sources is a book, which I couldn't check out. The next one is a short article on a site that says it is closing by March 1, 2020, but you can still see the article now. The third one is an ESPN site talking about the Supersisters card set, so the fact about Melanie Smith being in it is correctly cited with that.
 * This article is very short and doesn't include any pictures of Melanie Smith or Calypso, the horse she won the Olympics with. It also needs to talk more about her life, and how she now trains horses on her farm in Germantown, TN, just outside of Memphis, TN. It also needs to mention her other awards, such as winning the Show Jumping Triple Crown and being included in the TN Sports Hall of Fame. One of the sources is a book, which I couldn't check out. The next one is a short article on a site that says it is closing by March 1, 2020, but you can still see the article now. The third one is an ESPN site talking about the Supersisters card set, so the fact about Melanie Smith being in it is correctly cited with that.


 * Sources
 * Training (melaniesmithtaylor.com)
 * Riding With Life: Melanie Smith Taylor - The Plaid Horse Magazine
 * Remembering Calypso - Expert advice on horse care and horse riding (equisearch.com)

Option 2

 * Article Title
 * J. Terry Steib
 * Article Evaluation
 * This article is pretty complete on J. Terry Stieb's life, but it copied from another source. The sources that are listed aren't very good. The article needs to be re-written, and pictures of him should be added.
 * This article is pretty complete on J. Terry Stieb's life, but it copied from another source. The sources that are listed aren't very good. The article needs to be re-written, and pictures of him should be added.


 * Sources
 * Bishop Terry Steib - Catholic Diocese of Memphis (cdom.org)
 * Street named after Memphis Bishop Steib (wmcactionnews5.com)
 * Bishop James Terry Steib [Catholic-Hierarchy] (catholic-hierarchy.org)

Option 3

 * Article title
 * Rochelle Stevens


 * Article Evaluation
 * This article has good information, but there is more to say about the events she won, and what she is doing now. There is an event held every year in Collierville TN, called the Rochelle Stevens Invitational, that she runs, that is not mentioned in the article. The article could talk more about her life as well. They could also mention the Rochelle Stevens Foundation, which she started after the Olympics.
 * One of the sources goes to a very short Olympic Database fact line, the next one says Page Not Found, and the third one is a good article about her, where most of the information in the article seems to have come from. However, they are not actually cited anywhere. The article has no proper citations. Also, the second possible source for editing the article I listed below, is actually word-for-word what is in the Wikipedia Article. They copied from another source again! : ( (Note: The Talk page has this article assigned to someone else.)


 * Sources
 * Rochelle Stevens's Biography (thehistorymakers.org)
 * rochelle stevens : definition of rochelle stevens and synonyms of rochelle stevens (English) (sensagent.com)
 * ROCHELLE STEVENS FOUNDATION - HOME

Option 4

 * Article title
 * Article Evaluation
 * Sources
 * Sources
 * Sources

Option 5

 * Article title
 * Article Evaluation
 * Sources
 * Sources
 * Sources