User:DenisaPO/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Reindeer herding

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article to evaluate as im very interested in Reindeer herding, and did a presentation on the Sami peoples and reindeer herding for one of my previous courses.

Evaluate the article
reindeer herding

Lead section

The lead section detailed within this article provides a clear and interesting introduction sentence that would interest the reader to continue reading the article. The article is very detailed and informative, but isn't extremely long that it would result in the reader losing interest in the article.

Content

The content within this article is very clear and informative and relevant with a neutral tone, and no persuasive terminology. All information is up to date. Some of the citations are from reputable colleges and universities that focus on promoting and strengthening Sami First Nations culture, language, and social life.

Tone and Balance

The tone and balance within this article is very neutral and refrains from biased perspectives.

Sources and References

The sources and references within this article are obtained from Government websites, and Indigenous organizations. Source 1, source 6, and source 18, do open, however the page is not found, therefore the citation for these are not accurate within this article.

Organization and writing quality

The writing within this article is professional and clear, while not too difficult to understand the content.

Images and Media

The images inputted within this article are eye catching and allows the reader to understand the content a lot better.

Talk page discussion

The talk page discussion is pretty empty, however, there is a question that was posted inquiring about country representation.

Overall impressions

I quite enjoyed reading this article as it was very informative and interesting. I enjoyed it because, unlike some Wikipedia articles, this one is very short and to the point which allowed me to retain enough attention to read it in one quick and easy sitting. I think the article could be better improved by finding the correct and updated sources as mentioned above. Overall, I believe this article is complete and well developed.