User:DrCooper9/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
The Walking Dead (season 3)

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because the walking dead is my favorite tv show and I know a lot about it.

Evaluate the article
Lead section-The first sentence tells precisely what the page is about. It briefly talks about what is in the article but I feel it does not tell me everything that will be talked about. I feel it should also tell me that in the article it will talk about the Talking Dead and the home media releases page. The lead section only talks about the show and not everything that is in the article

Content- the content section is clear and easy to read and to navigate.

Tone and Balance- The article is neutral and do not see any sides picked on anything

Sources and References- Links and sub-links all open and the sources used are reasonable and reliable

Organization and writing quality- organization is well done and easy to flow. Writing flow is good and does not feel out of place.

Images and Media- Use of a graph was well used and images good. Not sure about one image and it is the limited edition bluray package. Seems as if they are trying to promote and sell the limited edition disk form.

Talk Page Discussion- Class c rated. Some conversations are people asking why a certain section should or should not be included. Another conversation is explaining that one section needs reliable sources cited.

Overall Impressions- I think this article is overall good. I do not see many problems with it.