User:Ecolby24/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1

 * Article title
 * Michel Nieva


 * Article Evaluation
 * There is only about a paragraph on his page, so it definitely needs more information, but the info seems relatively accurate and neutral. I have doubts about if the second citation used meets the criteria for Wikipedia but the first one looks good.


 * Sources
 * Not sure if he would fully qualify, as he is mainly known as a science fiction writer, but I would be focusing on his essay collection Tecnología y barbarie (a play-off of Sarmientos writing). Might even see if I could make a page about the collection rather than the person, if it turns out to make more sense. Not sure if I will totally understand it though, in order to write about it, also not sure if the essays are more society focused or a mix of society and literature?? Also really have to see if there is analysis on any of the article search websites. ￼Finding sources might be hard.

Option 2

 * Article title
 * José María Aricó


 * Article Evaluation
 * It is two sentences and a list of works. It is very bare bones, but it mentions that he was an essayist and a democratic socialist. Only has one citation connected to the information written, although two were provided.


 * Sources
 * ARICÓ, José María – | Diccionario Biográfico de las Izquierdas Latinoamericanas (cedinci.org)
 * Historia del Socialismo Internacional - La difusión y revisión del marxismo en América Latina: José María Aricó y el grupo Pasado y Presente - Ariadna Ediciones (openedition.org)
 * Norberto Galasso

Option 3

 * Article title
 * Pablo Rojas Paz


 * Article Evaluation
 * Only three sentences. It doesn't go in depth at all, obviously, about his essays, theories, or the reason he founded a magazine. There are also no sources cited that I could see.


 * Sources
 * Imperialismo baldio · ICAA Documents Project · ICAA/MFAH
 * Will probably have to see if there is anything on the academic website search engines.

Option 4

 * Article title
 * Eugenio Pucciarelli


 * Article Evaluation
 * Only two sentences provided. Only has one reference that leads to a poorly formatted website that I would be unable to tell if it is actually viable for Wikipedia. Definitely needs info on his theories, writings, and philosophy (quick skim seems to point to a potentially humanism framework).


 * Sources
 * Eugenio Pucciarelli | Open Library
 * It seems like I will find a lot of sources when I look in the academic search engine websites.

Option 5

 * Article title
 * Ezequiel Adamovsky


 * Article Evaluation
 * It is only a paragraph but has more information than most of the other people in this list. It has three sources provided and seems to be written impartially. Needs more info on his books and theories that cover topics such as anti-capitalism and globalization.
 * Sources
 * Ezequiel Adamovsky and Esteban Buch, La marchita, el escudo y el bombo: Una historia cultural de los emblemas del peronismo, de Perón a Cristina Kirchner (Buenos Aires: Grupo Planeta, 2016), pp. 367, pb. | Journal of Latin American Studies | Cambridge Core
 * Will also probably find a lot of sources when I look in the academic search engine websites.