User:EdgarCorrale0619/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Talk:Antiseptic

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article to evaluate because I had to choose a topic from the list that was provided to me. I browsed the list to see which article stood out the most to me and "antiseptic" really caught my eye.

Evaluate the article
1) In the very fist quotation, the article accidentally tags "Germicide" a punk rock ban when it obviously did not mean to do it. 2) The article does a good job at introducing the topic and allowing the read to know what the entire article will be about. I also appreciate how the author included the origin of the word "antiseptic."

3) The layout of the article is coherent and the wording of the sentence is easy to read to follow.

4) As far as citations, the article did a relative great job are citing good sources (peer reviewed articles, textbooks, no advertisements/sellers). I really appreciated that the article stayed away from sellers even when the article was citing antiseptics.

5) The length of the article is short, however, it appears that the main focus of the article is to give its readers a brief introduction and maybe help them find some resources to further their research.