User:Fiona Lupi/Gating (electrophysiology)/James722 Peer Review

Peer review
This is where you will complete your peer review exercise. Please use the following template to fill out your review.

General info

 * Ahorvath16, EleanorJeakle, Fiona Lupi, Tdalv98, Lucasp08, Annakaji
 * Link to draft you're reviewing: Gating (electrophysiology)

Lead
The beginning of the article is clear and concise as to what you are trying to explain in terms of gating within electrophysiology. I like the fact that there is a distinction of the fact that this is in regards to electrophysiology. There is also a good broad introduction into the basic logic that is required for understanding the process of gating.

Content
The content is great, a lot of good sources are used and a lot of relevant content is included. I would make sure that every place where there is a footnote there needs to be a source, I know y'all know this but just figured I'd remind y'all if you forgot one.

Tone and Balance

 * This is a difficult topic to be biased on and its obvious that the way y'all wrote was completely unbiased and just purely based on the facts of the topics. The information that you provide is backed up by proper citations and that will go a long way to lend credence to your writing.

Sources and References
The links work and they are connected to solid scholarly sources at least within the ones I looked at. There is a solid attention to detail when it comes to your sources, meaning that they are accurate and rather new in most cases. This will also make the points in the article have more validity within them.

Organization
Super easy to read and understand, I was impressed with the way you were able to explain the ideas behind gating and how it works. It may seem like an easy idea but not everyone will get the logic behind why these gates respond to voltage. I feel that you did a great job explaining it.

Images and Media

 * The images really helped explain the topic and I feel that they will be an immense help to anyone that still needs some clarification on what is going on in the process of gating.

Overall impressions

 * I would say this is a great article that really helped me have a better grasp on the topic of gating. Keep adding little things if it makes sense to and remember to add the proper citations to all the footnotes. Great job.