User:FrankChen1999/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Cycling in the United States

Taro Balls

2021 Chinese FA Cup

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
Cycling in the United States

I chose this article because I used to be a cyclist and only stopped because of safety concerns and the lack of bicycle infrastructure. I am interested in exploring what cycling in the US in like in general and ways to potential improve the quality of life for cyclists in the US.

Taro Balls

I chose this article because I love taro balls. They are delicious and I have always heard about them in China. I am interested in learning more about them, their history, and why they are so popular.

2021 Chinese FA Cup

I chose this article because I am a huge football fan. I used to watch Chinese football games live when I was in China and watched many FA Cup games. I still follow the Chinese FA Cup even when I am in America so I am interested in making this article more complete and up to par with other football competition articles.

Option 1

 * Article title
 * Cycling in the United States


 * Article Evaluation
 * Lead Section
 * - There is a lead content, it is concise and includes a table of contents for the rest of the article.
 * Content
 * - Content focuses mainly on bicycle law, which overlaps with Bicycle law in the United States and defeats the purpose of having a separate Wikipedia page about cycling in general.
 * - Data is not up to date.
 * - Can be expanded in terms of USA cycling, bicycle culture, and more.
 * Tone and balance
 * - Tone is neutral and unbiased.
 * Organization and writing quality
 * - Article is organized and divided into subcategories that makes sense.
 * - No spelling errors.
 * Sourcing
 * - Sources are diverse, neutral, and plenty considering the lack of content in the article itself.
 * Images and Media
 * - It only has one image and can definitely use some extra images to describe other aspects of cycling in the US.
 * Overall Impressions
 * - When compared to other similar Wikipedia pages like Cycling in New York City, this article is lacking in content.
 * - It can include more data about bike lanes, which American cities are more bike friendly, and their corresponding legislatures.
 * - It can expand on cycling as a sport in the US. USA Cycling is the governing body of cycling competitions in the US and they host regular races, which can be included in this article.
 * Talk section
 * - No activity in talk section.
 * - Currently a part of WikiProject United States, WikiProject Cycling, and WikiProject Transport.
 * - Rated as Start-class, High-importance.


 * Sources

Option 2

 * Article title
 * Taro ball


 * Article Evaluation
 * Lead Section
 * - There is a lead section but it is the only section in the entire article.
 * Content
 * - Content includes most basic information about taro ball, including origin, basic ingredients, and ways to serve.
 * - However, they are mostly surface-level and can be expanded.
 * Tone and balance
 * - Tone is neutral and unbiased.
 * Organization and writing quality
 * - No spelling errors.
 * - No subcategories with the topic, which makes reading unpleasant.
 * Sourcing
 * - No references listed.
 * Images and Media
 * - Includes one image and is well captioned.
 * - Can be expanded with other forms of snacks that include taro balls, such as milk tea, or shave ice.
 * Overall Impressions
 * - Article is neutral but lacking in content.
 * - Many topics that are mentioned can be explored deeper and supported with reliable sources.
 * Talk section
 * - The only talk section in the activity is my own critiques.
 * - A part of WikiProject Taiwan and WikiProject Food and drink.
 * - Rated as low importance and a stub.


 * Sources

Option 3

 * Article title
 * 2021 Chinese FA Cup


 * Article Evaluation
 * Lead Section
 * - There is a lead section and provides general information about the competition.
 * - Contents are subcategorized and there is a table of content.
 * Content
 * - Content includes schedule of the competition in terms of rounds, and subsequently matches in chronological orders.
 * - The final game is listed separately and includes information about substitutions made, nationalities of players, and referee information.
 * - However, when compared to other football competition articles, there is no detailed explanation regarding how teams are qualified, as well as how the competition is connected to the Chinese Super League.
 * Tone and balance
 * - Tone is neutral and unbiased.
 * Organization and writing quality
 * - No spelling errors.
 * - It is organized in chronological order and makes sense.
 * Sourcing
 * - There are some sources but all come from the same site.
 * - Heavily suggesting sourcing from a different site to preserve a neutural tone.
 * Images and Media
 * - No image included.
 * - Some ideas included images can be stadiums that host the final, or photos from matches, or even logo of the FA cup.
 * Overall Impressions
 * - Article is informational but very dry.
 * - Only provides information regarding the results of the competition.
 * - Can be expanded regarding its formats, its controversies, and how it connects to other competitions in Chinese football in terms of seeding, and qualifications.
 * Talk section
 * - No talk section activities.
 * - A part of WikiProject Football.
 * - Rated as low importance and a stub.
 * - Supported by the season article task force.


 * Sources