User:Frankiefoyjames/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
I Am Number Four

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I was just looking for something from the links provided. I went to "C-class," then children's lit, then this one because it had a title I thought I recognized.

Evaluate the article
Lead: (lede?): looks good

Content: Could use an update of sources for currency.

Tone: fine

Sources: basically fine, but there are two by one author and no source in the last 10 years

Organization: good

Images: uses cover--possibly could add image of author?

Talk page: Looks like some controversy that could be usefully included in the page. Additionally, some users think the plot summary is too long, while others appreciate it.

Overall: I wouldn't personally mess with this page, though someone with more knowledge might want to try to add the "controversy" section in.