User:Fylindfotberserk/sandbox


 * Why I am not in favor of sorting based on "Population"
 * 1) The word Population has multiple meanings when it comes to South Asians. For others it means "ethnolinguistic" groups and thus can be much more easily sorted alphabetically. South Asians have complex social stratification. Genetic tests have been done on the basis of Castes, Sub-Castes, Tribes, Clans, Religion, Language-families, Zones, States, Districts, Countries, etc. How is it reasonable to bring together e.g. Marathas(an ethnic group), Marathi Brahmin(a caste), Marathi Konkanastha Brahmin(a sub-caste), Marathi Tribals, Marathi Muslims when they belong to separate tiers on top of that we have entries like New Delhi(a city), India(West)(a zone), Hindus, Indo Aryan Low Castes, Sri Lanka(country) adding to the confusion. A reader ignorant of South Asian society might think Marathi and Marathi Brahmin to be separate "populations".
 * 2) There's a lot of ambiguity in some entries/sources. e.g Rajput, Chamar, Maharashtra Brahmins, Andhra Tribals are ambiguous groups since they have sub-groups and are multi-regional. We don't know from which specific ethnic group the samples have been taken. It is important because researches sometimes are revised and they sometimes refer to older papers. What if the name of sample population change in the new edition or in a newer research? As an example, Underhill 2009 referred some data from Battaglia et al. 2008. But it changed the name of some sample populations.
 * 3) If we sort (Indian Shia, Iranian Shia, Shia), (Madhya Pradesh Gonds (India), Uttar Pradesh (South) Gonds (India), Gujarat Bhils) or (Sunni vs Indian Sunni) together, the table wouldn't look alphabetically sorted defeating the whole purpose. I've explained that in the talk page.
 * 4) It is extremely tedious to put "Populations" Manually Alphabetically into table down to the last alphabet especially if the "Referenced Scholarly Article" has high number of Sampled groups and most of the time, the papers don't arrange sampled groups alphabetically in their tables.
 * 5) There seems no rule on how we should sort a table as per WP:SORT, so I don't see a need to consider other tables as a Standard for this table when there are a lot difference between them.

So either we get ethical and build an "All Encompassing" table with columns like Country, Caste, Tribe, Region which will only make our work cumbersome and future edits more difficult. Or we can sort as per Time of Publication and rid us of unnecessary hassles like this. After all, the sources are mostly primary and it is better to represent them as it is as per WP:PSTS.


 * Why I am in favor of sorting based on "Time of Publication"
 * 1) It is easier to put new research data into(based on year), easier to put whole tables almost as it is from the published sources, easier to put missed data into as it is(based on research) and is easier to refer to this article if it is based on month/year. And yes, I believe most readers have basic know how of genetic researches.
 * 2) It is much easier to cross verify entries with the source data.
 * 3) The table is sortable, alphabetic sorting is just one click away. There is no need to make it permanent when it has all the problems I listed above.

Worked on

 * 1) Very important 2017 Uttar Pradesh Legislative Assembly election
 * Hazel Keech
 * Zubeen Garg
 * Gurpreet Ghuggi
 * Guru Randhawa
 * Aneri Vajani
 * Binnu Dhillon
 * Asha Parekh
 * Varalaxmi Sarathkumar
 * Jagdish Nehra
 * Nirbhay Wadhwa
 * Isha Rikhi
 * Amarkant
 * Anas Rashid
 * Sonal Chauhan
 * Russell Mehta
 * Sonal Chauhan
 * Pankhuri Awasthy
 * Pradeep Pandey
 * Pradeep Rawat (actor)
 * Babul Supriyo
 * Sanjay Singh
 * Abhitej Singh Sandhu
 * Moloya Goswami
 * Kushal Punjabi
 * Mazhar Khan (actor, born 1955)
 * Dhruba Hazarika
 * Ashok Banthia
 * Nishita Goswami
 * Akon Bora
 * Yogeeta Bali
 * Pawni Pandey
 * Aranaiyur
 * Seeman (politician)
 * Kumar Vishwas
 * Ashraful Haque (actor)
 * Saswata Chatterjee
 * Sudarshan Faakir
 * Madhoo
 * Swapna Barman
 * Upendranath Barman
 * Jhataleka Malhotra
 * Rajeev Kumar Singh Lodhi
 * Rambha (actress)
 * Sangeeta Bijlani
 * Ananya Pandey
 * Nisith Pramanik
 * Akshaibar Lal cr
 * Prem Singh Tamang
 * Shilpa Shirodkar
 * Shyam Singh Yadav
 * Shalini Pandey
 * Nidhi Razdan
 * Rishi Dev
 * Shakti Anand
 * Sai Deodhar
 * Vijay Kumar Dubey
 * Ramji Gulati
 * Reema Debnath
 * Jamuna Boro
 * Ankushita Boro
 * Yashwant Singh (about template use)
 * Shankar Lalwani
 * Hanuman Beniwal
 * Meghna Malik
 * Bakhshish Singh Virk
 * Prarthana Behere
 * Ramesh Chand
 * Lalan Singh
 * Anup Upadhyay
 * Bhishma Shankar Tiwari
 * Rajesh Khattar
 * Vishal Singh (actor, born 1985)
 * Manjari Makijany
 * Kiran Rathod
 * Lakha Lakhwinder Singh
 * Sanghmitra Maurya
 * Nivedita Joshi-Saraf
 * Aditya Tamang
 * Raj Shekhar
 * Savi Sharma
 * Khagen Murmu
 * Swadhin Kumar Sarkar
 * Sreerupa Mitra Chaudhury
 * Gayatri Patel Bahl
 * Daisy Bopanna
 * V.P. Singh Badnore
 * Ramesh Bais
 * Lalji Tandon
 * Fagu Chauhan
 * Mumaith Khan
 * Rakesh Pandey (politician, born 1952) cr
 * Shariff Mohammed Ahmed cr
 * Malook Nagar extensive
 * Shiwani Saini
 * c|Category:Madhya Pradesh MLAs 2018- cr
 * Krishna Gaur cr
 * Ranjit Bawa - notable
 * Rakesh Pratap Singh (politician) - cr
 * Manohar Chandrikapure - cr
 * Leela Ram - cr
 * Category:Haryana MLAs 2019– - cr
 * Ram Bahadur Limboo - cr
 * Manoj Singh Mandavi - cr
 * Bob Biswas (film)
 * Dheeraj Bakliwal - cr
 * List of people from Amritsar - cr
 * Pratapgarh, Uttar Pradesh
 * Sharad Kumar Awasthi - cr
 * Bharat Bhushan Batra - cr
 * Wamiqa Gabbi
 * Rajesh Tripathi - cr
 * Pradeep Shukla - cr
 * Daya Shankar Singh - cr
 * Ragini Sonkar - cr
 * Sanjeev Agarwal - cr
 * Abhay Singh (politician) - cr
 * Rajeshwar Singh - cr
 * Fareed Mahfooz Kidwai - cr
 * Ganieve Kaur Majithia- cr
 * Ramesh Jaiswal - cr
 * Varun Chaudhary - cr
 * Chhotu Singh Bhati - cr
 * Sharadrao Kale - cr

Should create Shloka Mehta, Harivarman Dheeraj Bakliwal mayor Durg, ,


 * 1) Rashida Jones

Location, Show
Gujarat - Rajasaurus, Barabanki, Uttar Pradesh, Doom Dooma, Hero Vardiwala, Naigaon, Nanded

To check
Jeff Hardy, Tere Bin Kive Band Vaaje

To work on
Rana Ayyub, Mannara Chopra, Ram Charan, Rohit Jugraj Chauhan, Vikrant Singh Rajpoot, Antara Biswas, Pawan Singh, Mannara Chopra, Ila Arun, Parmeet Sethi, Upendra Trivedi, Akriti Kakar, Leema Dhar, Riya Dey, Vineet Kumar Singh, Devi Dutt Sharma, Chaya Singh, Veena Das (bare refs), Rohit Khandelwal, Nishita Goswami, Neha Saxena (TV actress), Sheela Kaur, Ashok Saraf, Ravi Deep, Nidhi Razdan, Martand Sun Temple, Barkha Madan. Ajmal Sultanpuri, Sukhpal Singh Khaira, Satyajeet Dubey, Sarvadaman D. Banerjee, Harshdeep Kaur, Suman Mukhopadhyay, Sonal Jha, Ujjwal Chopra, Adil Hussain, Parth Samthaan, Rajindar Nath Rehbar, Anuj Saxena, Yashpal Sharma (actor), Om Prakash Mathur, Rima Das, Tumpa Ghosh, Miya (actress), Nataša Stanković, Disco Shanti, Nanda Jichkar, Faisal Khan, Yash (actor), Kalpnath Paswan


 * Articles


 * Gauriganj, India

Trivia

 * Beware of script