User:GDC0605/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Beer in Syria --> Beer in Syria

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
It was related to my course studies and appeared interesting at face value. At face value, the page also appeared to have an interesting mix between the current and historical circumstances surrounding beer in Syria.

Evaluate the article
The article has a fairly good introduction that summarizes the article, but acts more as a summary or conclusion rather than an introduction. Also, given the size of the article, it is quite lengthy (relatively).

The content is all relevant and up to date, but somewhat lacking in terms of sources and insights.

The article is written from a neutral point of view, and has a neutral tone to go along with it.

Although most links work, some citations are still missing, and many of the citations there are of the same source type (lack of diversity in sources). This may be an issue due to the availability of the sources rather than a fault of the writer.

The page has effective media and pictures, but could certainly use one more in my opinion.

The talk page shows that someone believes the article is biased, and I wouldn't have held that opinion or thought to consider it until reading the talk page.

Overall, the article is interesting and well written, but lacks content.