User:GMT2020UPRC/Evaluate an Article

Evaluate an article
This is where you will complete your article evaluation. Please use the template below to evaluate your selected article.


 * Name of article: Effects of Hurricane Maria in Puerto Rico
 * I want to evaluate this article because Hurricane Maria was a moment where I spended with my family in my house, and we saw everything that happened around us. I´m still curious about a few things and today it´s the anniversary of when Hurricane Maria passed through Puerto Rico.

Sources and References

 * Guiding questions


 * Most of this is just basically a copy paste from the main page, so both would need rewriting. Plus, the Preperations section is severely lacking in information. The end of 1 paragraph lacks a citation to support the comparison is not significant. Additionally, reference formatting needs to be more similar. Either use MLA style or standard US date style. I haven't looked at the other aspects of the formatting, but you should check that out too.

Overall impressions

 * About the supporting materials, it has enough images and tables for the amount of material, although there are too many in places. Avoid placing tables and images right next to each other. Images should never sit right on top of one another.
 * About the grammar and styly, I did notice some quantity disagreements amongst some other grammatical issues.Just proofread the article. The article is a bit choppy in places as well due to sentences starting "On X date".
 * The structure is not well developed. The lead is far too small for an article of this size.
 * Several sections are lacking. Hurricane Irma did more than just knock out power. Preps need more detail as more did occur than what is mentioned. Damage estimates and economic impact is extremely small. Such a deadly and destructive storm would have had a massive effect on the economy.