User:Garfield Enthusiast/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Rock and roll

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because I have always been drawn to music and I always love learning about. One of my favorite genres of music is rock and roll so I thought this would be an interesting article to evaluate.

Evaluate the article
The article has a clear first sentence that explains what it is about. The lead section is short with four small paragraphs that explain what the whole article is about. The lead is not overly detailed and does not contain any information that isn't contained in the body of the article. The contents of the article is relevant to the topic. It goes over the history of the topic and how outside factors have influenced rock and roll. It speaks on the cultural influences that have shaped rock and roll, which a lot of people look over when thinking about this topic. It is very well written with all main parts broken up appropriately, making it easy to read and follow along. The article is written in a neutral standpoint. There are no claims that seem biased and are not trying to persuade anyone in any way. This article also contains images of some rock and roll legends that are important to the content of the article. The images are also relevant and talked about in the article. There are a lot of reliable sources and references throughout the whole article.

The article talk page has conversations about a section that someone wanted to add but got rejected. There is also a peer-review of the article that is now archived that say it is poorly organized and too long. I disagree, I think the article is not too long and well organized. My only criticism is that the information only covers until 1960s and does not go past that.