User:Glandavious/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Insectivore

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because I wanted to choose an animal related article, and I was able to think of things to add just glancing over this article.

Evaluate the article
The information contained in this article is good, but the problem lies more in the amount of information. I think there could be more categories within this article about insectivores. The only specific instance of insectivores brought up is plants, and there are many more insectivores that could be talked about.

The tone of this article seems fine to me. The writing done is from a neutral, factual standpoint. I did not feel as though there was any bias or underrepresented view points.

All of the sources in this article were well used and valid. There were quite a few from scientific journals, and most of those books are going to be paywalled. I did check and see that for at least a couple of them, the info was from the small amount you can read without paying, which is good. I didn't have time to check every scholarly source but some may reference information that isn't available to the general public.

The talk page has very little substance that shows careful deliberation and editing of this page. There are mainly just two people on there debating over a couple small things, and it is more of just an argument. There also hasn't been anything on the talk page since 2008.