User:Grantloseke/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
The Five Orders of Architecture

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because it is related to architectural history. This article matters, as it explain a book on the five different orders of architecture, which was important back in medieval times.

Evaluate the article
Lead Section


 * This lead section does have an introductory sentence that clearly describes the article's topic, but it is very detailed, not concise
 * This lead section does includes a description of the main sections
 * The lead section does not include information not present in the article
 * The lead is consice to a certain extent

Content


 * The content of the article is relevant to the topic. It mentions what is in the book, who the author is, and how the book is translated into various languages
 * The content is up to date.
 * No content was missing or no content that did not belong to the topic was included
 * No equity gaps were noticed.

Tone and Balance


 * This article is neutral, as it does not mention any bias towards a certain position.
 * No viewpoints are underrepresented or overrepresented, and no minority viewpoints were mentioned. This article does not have any persuasion at all.

Sources and References


 * All content but the contents section is backed up by a reliable secondary source
 * The sources are thorough. The sources are different books about architectural history.
 * The sources are current, and are written by different authors.
 * The sources are the best sources, as they are from real books, not internet sources.
 * The links work, they take me to Google Books, and shows part of the book.

Organization and Writing Quality


 * This article is well written; clear, concise, readable, no spelling/grammar errors, and broken down into sections covering the main points: author, contents, and different translations/editions

Images and Media


 * This article includes images that are relevant to the topic and are captioned well. The images are visually appealing and all adhere to the copyright regulations of Wikipedia

Talk page discussion


 * There aren't any conversations on how this topic is represented.
 * This article is part of several WikiProjects, including WikiProject Architecture, WikiProject Greece, WikiProject Italy, WikiProject Classical Greece and Rome, and WikiProject Books. The rating of the article depends on the WikiProject.
 * This article explains a book on the five different orders of architecture, which is different because, we talk about the history of different cities in class

Overall impressions


 * The overall status of the article is good, but can be more detailed
 * The strengths of the article is the sections are relevant to the topic.
 * The article can be improved by putting a little more detail in the contents section
 * This article is developed, but not enough to be well developed.