User:Guy0307/FR

Flagged Revisions could be either a good or a bad thing - depending on how we use it. Firstly, if we implement it on low-risk pages, it would create more bad than good - even in the unlikely case of vandalism in low-risk pages RCP can handle it. New users are likely to turn away from WP if they don't see their edit immediately - I would for sure. On semi-protected pages and BLPs it could be a good thing - however, it all depends on who is restricted and who isn't.

Jimbo had previously stated that he would like to see Flagged Revisions replacing semi-protection. Only non-autoconfirmed users can't edit semi-protected pages. Will they be the only group (together with IPs) who are restricted? Or will there be a new group replacing autoconfirmed, with stricter "entry conditions"? This is the important part in my opinion, and this is what will determine my position on flagged revisions.