User:HabeshaKid/sandbox

I chose to evaluate the Wikipedia article titled "Burkle Estate". Below is my evaluation.

Lead Section:

The lead section of this article is well-written. As a reader, I could get a clear picture on what the Burkle Estate was. The lead section did indeed briefly introduce the sub-sections of the article. Overall, I think this was a good lead section.

Content:

The content on this article is very good. The article accurately mentions two conflicting viewpoints on the Burkle Estate. The article also discusses slavery and African American history which does indeed deal with Wikipedia's equity gap. The only critique I have of the content of this article is the recency of the article's sources. Much of the article's content is based off sources from well over a decade ago. Additionally, the last message posted on this article's talk page was from 2010.

Tone and Balance:

The Burkle Estate has been a major source of controversy over whether or not it was actually a station in the Underground Railroad system. Therefore, I would expect that navigating through this controversy in a neutral way would be difficult. However, I think that the article did a good job of bringing a neutral perspective. The article accurately and fairly represents each side of the argument regarding the Burkle Estate. I did find one issue though: Some of the claims made in the article were not supported with a citation. This needs to be fixed.

Sources and Reference:

The sources of this article need the most attention. As I stated above, some of the claims in this article are not supported with a citation. Furthermore, most of the citations are out of date. In fact, the citations are so out of date that some of the links do not even work. The information and sources for this Wikipedia page need to be updated.

Organization and Writing Quality:

The organization and writing quality of this article is good. It is easy to understand and it is clearly organized with headings for each section.

Images and Media:

There is only one image in this article. The image does adhere to Wikipedia's Copyright policy. However, in my opinion a better image of the Burkle Estate could be uploaded.

Talk Page Discussion:

The talk page of this article was very helpful for me in discovering the state of the article. The talk page discusses the issues of citations as well as the two different viewpoints of the Burkle Estate. However, the last talk page post was in 2010. This article is a part of WikiProject Museums. The article is classified as "Start-Class" on Wikipedia's quality scale. This means that the article needs significant improvement and more information for it to be more informational and helpful to readers.

Overall Impressions:

Overall, this article needs a lot of improvement. Although things like the tone, organization, and lead section are very well done. The content is outdated and more citations need to be added. Also, more information in general needs to be added to this article.