User:Herostratus/sandbox2

Let's start with xxxx WP:PROD. As you know, WP:PROD starts with

(Emphasis in original). My thesis here as there's a minimum level of competence for what one considers "expected". So let's see. xxxx has xx of making a log of his activities in this area, which, thank you very much xxx, an this is helpful.

First I'm going to look at a subject, board games. Piotrus does not, I infer, care much for board games, which fine, don't play them. Don't read about them. But don't prevent everyone else from reading about them.. Sorry, but if the shoe fits... let's see if the shoe fits. Working backwards chronologically:


 * April 2021: none
 * March 2021: none
 * February 2021:
 * Super Jock, deprodded by User:Andrew Davidson, send by User:Piotrus to Articles for deletion/Super Jock, kept as No Consensus due to "minimal participation" (FWIW, "vote" was 2 Delete, 1 Keep, 2 not voting.)
 * Bookshelf game, PROD declined by User:Maury Markowitz
 * Isolation (board game), PROD accepted by User:Explicit
 * Atlanta (board game), PROD rolled back by User:Piotrus due to article improvements
 * Battle-Cry (Milton Bradley game), PROD removed by User:Andrew Davidson, sent by User:Piotrus to Articles for deletion/Battle Cry (Milton Bradley game), result was Keep (FWIW "vote" was 5-2 Keep). That's... not a good look for an article that was PRODded as self-evidently worthless. (IMO PRODding Battle Cry is kind of like PRODding, I don't know, The Lost Boy (novella) or Masquerade (play) or whatever. It'd be trollery. Battle-Cry is really famous and important. I get that User:Piotrus might not know that, but a lot of editors might not know that about Masquerade (play) etc. That doesn't mean that "never heard of it, I'll PROD" is OK.)


 * January 2021:
 * [All in! Games SA deprodded by [User:Atlantic306]]
 * GI Assault Team, material voluntarily deleted (converted to a redirect) by article creator

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

JANUARY, we have 33 PRODs.
 * 13 still exist (10 by dePROD, 1 sent to AfD and survived, PROD sef-reverted, 1 unclear)
 * 1 doesn't exist as separate article, but its material was merged into another (per AfD)
 * 19 don't exist (15 PROD accepted, 3 sent to AfD and deleted, 1 voluntarily deleted)

So, close to half of Pitrous's PRODs were not deleted... Is this a high number? You tell me, but it seem high to me as I would think that over 90% of PRODs would be either deleted, either right off or else sent to AfD where they would almost all be deleted. I mean PROD is meant for obvious garbage. Isn't it?

---Kept---

PROD rolled back by Piotrus after after further article development:
 * self-reverted: Princess Maria Carolina of Bourbon-Two Sicilies (1856–1941)

Deprodded and the matter dropped:
 * Princess Isabel Alfonsa of Bourbon-Two Sicilies deprodded by [User:Less Unless]]
 * [All in! Games SA deprodded by [User:Atlantic306]]
 * European League of Football -- it is not clear what happened here. Piotrus says his PROD was on 7 January 2021, but the article was (re?)created on 14 February, and there aren't any edits by Piotrus or an ex-PROD notice on talk.
 * Yahoo (Gulliver's Travels) deprodded by User:Andrew Davidson
 * Josh Mosqueira deprodded by User:Haleth
 * Kevin Martens deprodded by User:Dream Focus
 * Show'N Tell deprodded by User:Chowbok
 * Darkhold deprodded by User:Haleth (partly on basis of tagged for merge)
 * Just'a Lotta Animals deprodded by User:Etzedek24
 * Groan Tube deprodded by User:Andrew Davidson
 * Imaginarium SA deprodded by User:Andrew Davidson

Deprodded and then sent to AfD:
 * Struldbrugg, deprodded by User:Andrew Davidson, nominated for Articles for deletion/Struldbrugg, kept. FWIW "vote" was 6-2 to keep (1 speedy). This seems an odd result for a PROD. I see that one commenter noted that while Piotrus had claimed to have performed WP:BEFORE diligence, he had not, and thus WP:CIR and WP:HONESTY were in play.

Material kept, but merged into another article:
 * Bedtime toy, deprodded by User:Andrew Davidson, sent to Articles for deletion/Bedtime toy by User:Reywas92, Merged. (FWIW "vote" was 3-1 for Delete, 2 for Merge.)

---Deleted---

Deleted (FWIW redirect exists)
 * GI Assault Team, voluntarily converted to a redirect by article creator
 * Gurglin Gutz, deprodded by User:Andrew Davidson, sent by Piotrus to Articles for deletion/Gurglin Gutz, Deleted. (FWIW "vote" was 3-1 to delete.)
 * William Hamley, deprodded by User:Andrew Davidson, sent by Piotrus to Articles for deletion/William Hamley, Deleted. (FWIW "vote" was 3-1 to delete, 1 merge.
 * Steve Elliot, sent to Articles for deletion/Steve Elliott (character, by xxxx, Deleted. (FWIW "Vote" was 5-1 to delete).

Deleted (FWIW no redirect exists). (There's no data available to me for these articles since they're deleted and there was no AfD discussion. To be honest they're probably mostly pretty poor):
 * Sam Drucker, PROD accepted by User:Explicit
 * Mr. Haney, PROD accepted by User:Explicit
 * Hank Kimball, PROD accepted by User:Explicit
 * Herbert Kaliga, PROD accepted by User:Explicit
 * Model Ball, PROD accepted by User:Explicit
 * Committee of adjustment, PROD accepted by User:Voice of Clam
 * Artie 3000, PROD accepted by User:Explicit
 * Slop (remote control), PROD accepted by User:Explicit
 * Radio-controlled hovercraft, PROD accepted by User:Explicit
 * Ohbot, PROD accepted by User: Liz
 * Meccanoid, PROD accepted by User: Liz
 * Photoblaster, PROD accepted by User: Liz
 * Eye popper, PROD accepted by User: Liz
 * Get in Shape Girl, PROD accepted by User: Liz
 * The Infaceables, PROD accepted by User: Liz

FEBRUARY 2021 Alright. This is a lot of work. Let's just summarize and cherry-pick here.

xxx PRODs. xxxxx exist Super Jock

37 deleted (37 with no redirect, xxx