User:Historian1970

Dear Historian1970 - whilst I appreciate you have your own views on Border Morris, to delete much of the original article and the evidence cited therein also constituted vandalism. If you have alternate interpretations, fine, but then you should write the article in such a way that both viewpoints are preserved, not to simply delete the original material and put in claims that the whole thing is a racist minstrel show. I'm not sure what your interest or knowledge of Border Morris is, as you post anonymously. However, I dance with Silurian Border Morris, grew up in the villages that dances were collected from, and personally knew/know Dave Jones and Keith Francis who collected the dances in the late 1960's from the old guys in the villages. There was no element of minstrel in what was collected and these primary sources of collection were all clear that the reason for the black face was disguise. There is also written evidence (which you deleted from the original article) that mentions the black face and morris back in the 14th Century - 500 years before minstrel shows. By all means add a section of modern North America interpretations of border morris, but please do so in a balanced way. Paul (talk)