User:Hordaland/ADHD

Requests for amendment
-- To request changes to remedies or enforcement provisions, for example to make them stronger or deal with unforeseen problems.

... all requests for the amendment of closed cases are to be made in a standard format; a request for amendment of a closed case must clearly state the following:
 * (a) The name of the case to be amended;
 * (b) The clause(s) to be modified, referenced by number or section title;
 * (c) For each clause in (b), the desired modification; and
 * (d) The rationale for the requested amendment, comprising no more than 1000 words.

How to file a request for amendment or appeal
 * 1) Copy the request template in the box below.
 * 2) Open the arbitration requests page, go to the section called Requests for amendment, appeal, and clarification.
 * 3) Paste in the following template immediately below  ==Current requests==  and above any other outstanding requests.
 * 4) Using the format provided by the template, list any other affected or involved users and enter and sign your statement.
 * 5) If your request will directly affect other users, you must notify each involved person on their user talk page. Return to your request and provide diffs showing that other involved users have been notified in the section provided for notification.
 * 6) If you are having trouble you may contact a Clerk, or post a request for help on the Request for Arbitration talk page.

Request to amend prior case: Case name = ADHD

 * Case affected :


 * Clause to which an amendment is requested


 * 1) Remedy 3) Scuro placed under mentorship
 * is placed under mentorship for a period of one year. Scuro shall find a mentor of his choice, and shall inform the Committee once the mentor has been selected; if no mentor is found within one month of the closure of this case, the Committee will appoint a mentor. The terms of the mentorship must cover guidance on Wikipedia's sourcing and citation guidelines, but otherwise Scuro and the mentor are free to decide on the terms. Once an agreement on the terms is reached, Scuro or the mentor shall advise the Committee of the terms by email.
 * Passed 10 to 0 to 1, 00:03, 14 July 2009 (UTC)


 * List of users affected by or involved in this amendment
 * (initiator)


 * Confirmation that the above users are aware of this request
 * Username2 (diff of notification of this thread on Username2's talk page)
 * Username3 (repeat above for all parties)
 * Username4
 * Username5
 * Username6

Amendment 1

 * Arbitration/Requests/Case/ADHD
 * Desired modification (additions in bold):
 * is placed under mentorship for a period of one year. Scuro shall find a mentor of his choice, and shall inform the Committee once the mentor has been selected; if no mentor is found within one month of the closure of this case (that is, by 15 August 2009), the Committee will appoint a mentor. The terms of the mentorship must cover guidance on Wikipedia's sourcing and citation guidelines and observation of and assistance with effective communication on talk pages, but otherwise Scuro and the mentor are free to decide on the terms. Once an agreement on the terms is reached, Scuro or the mentor shall advise the Committee of the terms by email. Until said mentor is in place and the terms are approved by Scuro, the mentor and the Committee, Scuro is topic banned from editing articles and talk pages defined in "Topic area" above, broadly construed.

Statement by Hordaland

 * The situation on Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and related pages including WikiProject Medicine/Collaboration of the Week (MCOTW) is at present much the same as it was this spring, before arbitration. Scuro talks (and sometimes lectures) about collaboration, true consensus building, a new start/beginning, NPOV, undue weight, the ball is in your court, be willing to come to the table, etc., but in a way that most other editors see as delaying tactics or otherwise not constructive.  When he talks about "majority opinion" and "minority opinion", it is plain that he feels that he represents the majority while most other editors belong to a minority or fringe.  Scuro has knowledge and views which I believe should be heard but his methods of communicating are not conducive to the kinds of cooperation needed to write an encyclopedia. I would like to see him learn from a very good and patient mentor; without that, the situation is again intolerable.  Since Scuro states that the mentor (he calls it "mediator") should only be concerned with citations, the requested amendment is necessary.  Quote: "By the way I've followed all of my obligations with regards to arbitration, and the mediator was specifically for citations only."


 * I am aware that Literaturegeek has filed a request regarding another remedy in the same case. That one and mine may be combined, if that is agreeable to the Committee and other parties.

Statement by other editor
{Other editors are free to comment on this amendment as necessary. Comments here should be directed only at the above proposed amendment.}

Amendment 2

 * Link to principle, finding of fact, or remedy to which this amendment is requested
 * Details of desired modification

Statement by your username (2)
{Statement by editor filing request for amendment. Contained herein should be an explanation and evidence detailing why the amendment is necessary.}

Statement by other editor (2)
{Other editors are free to comment on this amendment as necessary. Comments here should be directed only at the above proposed amendment.}

Further discussion

 * Statements here may address all the amendments, but individual statements under each proposed amendment are preferred. If there is only one proposed amendment, then no statements should be added here.

Clerk notes

 * This section is for administrative notes by the clerks (including clerk recusals).

Arbitrator views and discussion


[END TEMPLATE]

The (original) remedies
ADHD ArbCom, remedies: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/ADHD#Remedies

Notifications
Heading:

Notification of a NEW request to amend ArbCom case

A new request for amendment of the ADHD remedies has just been filed. This one asks for additions to Remedy 3) Scuro placed under mentorship. This notification is being added to the talk pages of scuro, Literaturegeek, Jmh649, Unionhawk and WhatamIdoing.  - Hordaland (talk) 09:29, 19 September 2009 (UTC)

Diffs:

Scuro:

scuro

Literaturegeek:

Literaturegeek

Jmh649:

Jmh649

Unionhawk:

Unionhawk

WhatamIdoing:

WhatamIdoing