User:Howard Lewis

Replacement of entire text of Dumas, fils article
You replaced the entire text of the article with his own words. Your justification was "Complete and necessary re-write giving a proper overview of Dumas's work and life." There were several problems with this. * The formatting was incorrect, leaving the entire text as a single paragraph. * The replacement text does not have any useful wikilinks. * The replacement text does not have correctly formatted references. I was not the person who undid your edit, but I believe it was the correct thing to do. I noticed that nobody had properly explained any of the issues. I think it would be grand if you could edit the article one piece (paragraph?) at a time. That would give other users of the article time to see the reasoning for each piece that you put in. Ccady (talk) 23:36, 5 January 2009 (UTC)