User:Huldra/Dauphin & Finkelstein & SWP





This is a page for dropping links to pages where these two are wrong, + other notes.

Dauphin
Also: search for Dauphin- on User:Huldra/HA
 * 630:  Al-Bassa  Grid-typo:(1539/2759), should be around (163/275)
 * 740-741: Ma'ale Iron Guérin, Samarie I, 456-57 is Salim, Nablus (!)
 * 756: Baqa-Jatt Samarie II, 345-36 typo for Samarie II, 345-46
 * 756: Zeita, Tulkarm gives  Guérin, Samarie II, 173: Zeita...but that is Zeita Jamma'in
 * 798: Hajjah, Qalqilya should be SWP II 166, (not 168) and map XI, (not XL)
 * 807: Jamma'in should be should be SWP II, 284, not  SWP II, 384
 * 809: Marda, Salfit grid-typo (1638/1688)
 * 815:   Rafat, Salfit wrong SWP ref:   SWP II, 296, should be   SWP II, 286
 * 822:   Al-Lubban al-Gharbi Guerin-ref wrong, (due to old mix-up on SWP). correct ref. is Guérin, Samarie II, 112-3, and SWP II, 360, Talk:Al-Lubban ash-Sharqiya and Talk:Al-Lubban al-Gharbi
 * 830: see Talk:Sarafand al-Amar
 * 842: Salbit grid-typo: (1849.1419) should be more like 148.141 (changed 8 and 4?)
 * 880:  Talk:Al-Qubayba, Hebron : Guérin, Judée II, 299-303: Khirbet Oumm El-Lakis is nowhere near Al-Qubayba. But Guerin identified (wrongly) Khirbet Oumm El-Lakis with Lachish (which is near). Therefor the mixup.

Finkelstein

 * p. 152:   see  Talk:Khirbat Al-Lawz
 * p. 245: gives grid no. for  Al-Lubban al-Gharbi as 153  160, should be  153  170.
 * p. 563: see  Talk:Ein Yabrud
 * p. 750:  see  Talk:Al-Mughayyir, Ramallah

Finkelstein eras
From  pp. 18-19:
 * UP Upper Paleolithic
 * Natuf Natufian
 * Chal Chalcolithic
 * EB I Early Bronze age. Ancient Near East: nothing, really. Better link: Bronze Age
 * EB II-III
 * EB unclassified Early Bronze age
 * IB intermediate Bronze age Ancient Near East
 * MB "Generally, survey assemblages from the highlands do not permit subdivision into MB I (Albright's MB IIA), MB II and MB III. Still, it is clear that MB I material is almost absent in southern Samaria as in other parts of the central hill country. Hence, most of the material collected in the survey is dated to the MB II-III" ... best link(?): Bronze Age ==>  Middle Bronze Age
 * LB Ancient Near East  or Bronze Age
 * LB/IA I  Sherds, mainly cooking-pots, that could belong to either period.  Ancient Near_East


 * lA I Iron Age I (12-11th centuries B.C.E.)  Ancient_Near_East or Iron Age
 * lA I - II This phase, apparently the 10th and early 9th centuries B.C.E., Ancient Near East  or Iron_Age
 * IA unclassified Iron age
 * lA II   the 8th century B.C.E   Ancient_Near_East or   Iron_Age  ==>  Iron Age II


 * Per Achaemenid Empire  ==>  Persian
 * Per/Hell late Persian or early Hellenistic period ==> Persian/Hellenistic
 * Hell Hellenistic period  ==> Hellenistic
 * Hell-Rom typical 1st century BCE
 * Hell/Rom unclassified Hellenistic or Roman  era  ==> Hellenistic/Roman
 * Rom Roman Empire
 * Rom/Byz unclassified Roman or Byzantine sherds
 * Byz Byzantine sherds  Byzantine Empire ==> Byzantine
 * Byz/Umay  Byzantine Empire/  Umayyad Caliphate   ==>   Byzantine/Umayyad
 * Umay/Abbas  Umayyad Caliphate/Abbasid Caliphate  ==> Umayyad/Abbasid
 * Crus/Ayyub  Crusader states/  Ayyubid dynasty ==> Crusader/Ayyubid
 * Mam  Mamluk Sultanate (Cairo) ==> Mamluk
 * EOt early Ottoman empire  ==> early   Ottoman

SWP

 * Talk:Hamama
 * Talk:Tall al-Turmus
 * Talk:Kaukab Abu al-Hija
 * Talk:Al-Jalama, Haifa
 * Talk:Al-Lubban ash-Sharqiya mixed up over Guerins Al-Lubban al-Gharbi
 * Talk:Afula mixed up Fula/Afulah
 * Talk:Nabi Samwil
 * Talk:Sarafand al-Kharab
 * Talk:Shilta??
 * Talk:Yajur,_Haifa

Zertal

 * Constantly mix up the Abd al-Ghani date; between 1105 AH (=1693 CE); and 1105 CE(!)
 * Talk:Zawiya, Jenin Zertal, 2004, p. 201
 * Talk:Al-Attara Zertal, 2004, p. 272


 * Talk:Ar'ara Zertal, 2016, p. 132
 * Talk:Arraba, Jenin: Zertal, 2016, p. 378


 * Ya'bad see this