User:Ice Cold Beer/To Create

Allegations of state terrorism by the United States
Initiated by  Inclusionist (talk) 04:48, 13 May 2008 (UTC)

Involved parties

 * Confirmation that all parties are aware of the request`




 * Confirmation that other steps in dispute resolution have been tried


 * Talk:American terrorism/Past disagreements Including third party mediator and RfC about entire contents of this article.
 * Request mediation? - Straw Poll


 * 8 nominations for deletion, one of the most protected pages on Wikipedia, numerous editors banned because of sockpuppets used on the page, numerous ANIs

Statement by User:Inclusionist
I have been editing this page for almost three years, more than any other editor except Tom Harrison. Like the September 11 pages this page has been a constant battleground. I could bring up the edit behavior of several editors, and they could return in-kind. But I am not here to punish anyone, I simply want adult supervision on this page, to stop the edit warring.

There are a lot of fictions on wikipedia. For example: AfD are not "votes" (despite once being called voting). Another fiction is that the Arbcom does not rule on content disputes. The reality is that the Arbcom does rule on content disputes indirectly, they just let other administrators divvy out the enforcement.


 * 1) Requests for arbitration/Great Irish Famine where a mentor was set up on the page, and
 * 2) Requests for arbitration/September 11 conspiracy theories in which strict restrictions where put in place on these pages

Are just two examples. Inclusionist (talk) 06:11, 13 May 2008 (UTC)

Clerk notes

 * This area is used for notes by non-recused Clerks.