User:Imantodes/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Agalychnis callidryas

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I study these frogs, and have since 1991. Thus, I know the research on them and was curious to see how accurately Wikipedia is representing the state of knowledge.

Evaluate the article
I'm not going to do a full eval (time constraint) but just say this page has some claims I'd consider unsubstantiated by any scientific evidence, even though they are prevalent in the popular literature. Most prominently, the antipredator function of "flash colors" in this frog has, to my knowlege, never been tested and there's no evidence in support of it. The citation for that is a Nat. Geo. article that has no legitimate source behind it. The article is also written as "tree frog" (so wrong!) throughout when it should be "treefrog". That point has been addressed (correctly) in the talk page but apparently it keeps getting changed back. Those errors would be easy to fix.