User:Isaac Hopkins2801/Zack Snyder's Justice League/Isaac Hopkins2801 Peer Review

Peer review
This is where you will complete your peer review exercise. Please use the following template to fill out your review.

The Wikipedia page for Zack Snyder's Justice League, originally created by Wikipedia user TheJoeBro64, shows promise, but ultimately lacks some of the foundations that well-evaluated works possess.

Lead Evaluation

The Lead to this article is done well enough. Admittedly, there are virtually no links to any information, but that all relevant information is cited afterwards. Information is presented clearly and concisely as possible with such a complex topic.

Content Evaluation

Despite the successful attempts of many to provide new information about the topic as the situation currently is progressing, information is missing or under-supported in key areas of discussion. For instance, when discussing the production of the movie Zack Snyder's Justice League, the article says, "A final run-time and picture lock were achieved, though the cuts had incomplete visual effects shots and partial audio mixing." Although term definitions were provided for both picture lock and visual effects, a source for this information was nowhere to be found. A simple search inside of a database told me that this fact was confirmed by the storyboard artist for the movie, Jay Olivia, on one of his personal social media accounts. Yet this article provides no evidence to that fact, or at least no link to the evidence, to prove this information's accuracy. What seems odd to me, though, is that there are many sources from this page which were published only this year. How can this page be so inconsistent despite the numerous sources that have been added recently?

Tone and Balance Evaluation

Furthermore, this page provides a plethora of articles at its disposal, but the viewpoint is still extremely biased. This article is plastered with celebrities and fans who wished the infamous Snyder Cut into fruition yet makes one paragraph notice of the movement's detractors. On this page, the biased viewpoint makes this movement seem like it was much larger than it actually was and had very little detractors from skeptics when in reality this is not true. The harsh truth is that this small movement faced, and undoubtedly still faces, a large amount of skepticism and negative press. Rumors surrounding the Snyder Cut revolved for over 2 years after the theatrical cut's release with nothing to show for them. The movement itself didn't gain mainstream traction until 2019, when more stars from the troubled film, such as Jason Momoa and Ray Fisher, began to speak up in its favor on their social media accounts. The movie's director Zack Snyder himself spoke to the film's existence and there will still doubters. At that time, the movement was estimated to be under 10k Twitter users. Even now, the official Twitter account of the #ReleaseTheSnyderCut has amassed only 30k followers. Make no mistake, the people who wanted this movie to be released were in the minority. The majority opinion was either this film would never be released, it didn't exist in the first place, or the film would suck provided the former two proved to be true.

Sources and References Evaluation

While not all of these sources are what one might consider as professional, there are multiple links to websites which confirm the page's claims. After I checked a few of them, I determined that they were all functional. Most of these sources are very current, over half of them were written this year, 2020. Again, my only issue with these sources is that they projected a false narrative about the popularity of this director's cut.

Organization Evaluation

The information is presented clearly enough, with several different sections being dedicated to differences between the theatrical cut and the director's cut, the history of this film, and how it came to be scheduled for release. I spotted no grammatical errors as I read, so kudos to the users who edited this page. I would argue, however, that the detractors of the film and negative reaction towards it should have been in its own category, there was simply so much ground to cover.

Images and Media Evaluation

The images included with this page don't provide any further depth to the page. The only two photos included are a promotional photo of the movie and a picture of the film's director, Zack Snyder. The photos' captions relay this information to us, respectively. These images do adhere to Wikipedia's copyright regulations.

Overall Impressions
I would say that the content of the page has been improved dramatically since it's creation. Not everything here is perfectly done, but these things can be easily fixed. The strengths of this article includes the number of sources used and organization. The content can be improved by revising the narrative and citing sources whenever possible, not just in some places.