User:IsaiahCastro/Choose an Article

Article Selection
(Sorry couldn't figure out why the links won't work)

Option 1

 * Dark earth - Wikipedia
 * This article's content is relevant to the topic with the exception of a few sentences. The introduction could benefit from adding a description of the major sections. The article is written very neutrally as it is not a controversial topic. Some claims need citations added, but the sources currently cited are reliable. This article does not tackle a Wikipedia equity gap. The article would benefit from more pictures, possibly a diagram of black earth. Wording could be improved in many of these sentences. In need of a clearer and more concise and scientific description of how black earth is created. Detecting prehistoric fire-based farming using biogeochemical markers - Zurich Open Repository and Archive (uzh.ch)  Indigenous African soil enrichment as a climate&amp;#x2010;smart sustainable agriculture alternative (sussex.ac.uk)

Option 2

 * Broken Mammoth - Wikipedia
 * This article’s content is relevant to the topic BUT the content could be arranged better, and the page would benefit from using a more varied number of references. The article is written neutrally as it is not a controversial topic, and most claims have a citation but a few needs one. The article has no pictures and is in need of pictures and or graphs to help visualize along with reading. This article is a part of three Wik projects; Alaska, Archeology, and Indigenous peoples of North America. The talk page mentions some non-working links. Broken Mammoth (alaska.gov)  (PDF) Late Pleistocene/Early Holocene site structure in Beringia: a case study from the Broken Mammoth site, Interior Alaska | Kathryn Krasinski - Academia.edu

Option 3

 * Archaeology of Ancient Egypt - Wikipedia
 * This article's content is relevant, but it lacks good sources, according to the talk page of all the sources only “one or two are professional journals”. This article is hard to take seriously without many professional references. The content is written neutrally. Many claims need citations. Much of this article would have to be reworked with proper sources of the claims. The Journal of Egyptian Archaeology: SAGE Journals (sagepub.com)  The Journal of Egyptian Archaeology on JSTOR

Option 4

 * Article title
 * Article Evaluation
 * Sources
 * Sources
 * Sources

Option 5

 * Article title
 * Article Evaluation
 * Sources
 * Sources
 * Sources