User:Itsbaroque/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Brutalist architecture

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
It relates to my topic.

Evaluate the article
Lead Section:

-Concise and lets you know what they will be covering.

-subheadings relate to topicContent:

-relates and was last updated Nov 7,2022

Tone & Balance:

-good tone and balance

Sources:

-most are between 2015-2020

- has sources about brutalism from different countries

-scholarly sources

-links work

Organization and Writing

- easy to read

- didnt see any errors

Images and Media:

-has a gallery section as well as pictures throughout the article

-well captioned included name,year, place

Talk Page Diss:

-is it apart of the Architecture Wiki Project

-C class rating

-discourse about where the name brutalism came from and also some options in the article

-as well as how the topic should be organized

-people are being kinds upfront and mean

— differs from class cause we were told to be nice, but they still seem to be communicating effectively

Overall Impression:

-there’s controversy on who used the term brutalism and new brutalism

- the lead section is also critiqued as well as some sources (they were removed)

- last edited sept 25,2022

- i think it is developed and finally left alone after all the arguing between two Wikipedians