User:Ivychen0619/Evaluate an Article

 Evaluation of Article: Jiangxi cuisine 

General check

1. Is the article's content relevant to the topic?

Yes, this article's content is relevant to the topic, and it already has some basic information related to the topic.

2. Is it written neutrally?

Yes, there is no personal opinion currently existing in the content of the articles

3. Does each claim have a citation?

No, many citations need in the content of this article

4. Are the citations reliable?

Because there is a lack of citation for most of the claims so the answer for this question will be yes or no for right now.

5. Does the article tackle one of Wikipedia's equity gaps (coverage of historically underrepresented or misrepresented populations or subjects)?

No.

Lead Section Check


 * The current content of this article has an introductory sentence that concisely and clearly describes the article's topic. Still, I believe it can add more information about the significant characteristic of the topic. The current introductory sentence is too concise in which only describes where this cuisine came from.
 * The lead lacks a brief description of the articles' major sections but only describes the topic with one concise sentence.
 * The lead does not have any information is not present in the article.
 * The lead is overly concise and should be adding more detailed information about the topic, like the significant taste of Jiangxi cuisine.

Content


 * The current content of this article is relevant to the topic.


 * The content is up-to-date.


 * The current content is missing various information related to the topic, but there is no content that does not belong.


 * The article does not deal with any of Wikipedia's equity gaps.

Tone and Balance


 * The article is neutral, and there are no claims that seem heavily biased for any position.
 * There are no overrepresented or underrepresented viewpoints, while no minority viewpoints exist in the content of this topic.
 * The content of this topic does not attempt to persuade the audience in any position or oppose any side.

Sources and References


 * Since this article basically lacks most of the information, there is not much content added to this article. The current content lacks any sources and references besides Wikipedia. All the sources that appear on the references are link related to all other Wikipedia articles and all the links from Wikipedia work.

Organization and writing quality


 * The article can be considered well-written. All the content in the Characteristics section is straightforward and easy to read.


 * There are no grammatical or spelling errors in the current content of this article.


 * This article is not well-organized since it only has one section in the content. The information related to the topic is not enough for current content.

Images and Media


 * There is no image in the article that helps the reader better understand the topic, and more pictures should be added.

Talk page discussion


 * There is no conversation appearing on the Talk page, and this article has been rated as Stub-Class on the project's quality scale and has not yet received any rating on the project's importance scale.


 * It is not part of WikiProjects.

Overall impressions


 * The overall status of this article needs more editing, and more information should be provided about this topic. This article is currently in low completeness.


 * The editor can improve the content of this article by adding more
 * basic information(definition, characteristics)
 * the type of cuisine made up of Jiangxi cuisine/genre) about Jiangxi cuisine
 * the history of Jiangxi cuisine
 * Jiangxi cuisine legend
 * famous dishes in Jiangxi cuisine(with images provided)
 * the characteristic of these dishes and how to cook it
 * Nature and Charm of Jiangxi cuisine(why people like it)
 * possible other information realted with this cuisine

Which article are you evaluating?
Jiangxi cuisine (Jiangxi cuisine)

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
Jiangxi can be considered one of my hometowns, my mother was born and raised in Jiangxi Province. I went to Jiangxi to visit my aunt and grandmother from my mother's side every Chinese New Year and tasted various delicious Jiangxi dishes. When I found out there is not enough information related to Jiangxi cuisine on Wikipedia, I felt a little upset, and I am eager to spread the Jiangxi cuisine to the world. I want to let the world know about various delicious dishes in Jiangxi cuisine and attract people worldwide to travel to Jiangxi if possible.

Evaluate the article
(Compose a detailed evaluation of the article here, considering each of the key aspects listed above. Consider the guiding questions, and check out the examples of what a useful Wikipedia article evaluation looks like.)