User:Jéské Couriano/ArbCaseSum/09

=How to read the sections=
 * Decided: The calendar date (in UTC) when the case was decided. If the case did not reach a decision, it will be Closed instead. If the case involved an administrator "retiring", it will be "Deopped" instead.
 * Abbrev.: A shorthand abbreviation of the casename. See ArbCaseAbv for more details.
 * Type: The type of case it is:
 * Admin: A case centred around the conduct of one or more administrators.
 * Dispute: A case that examines an intractible dispute between two or more editors directly.
 * Editor: A case about the (non-administrative) misconduct of an editor.
 * Functionary: A case centred around misuse of Suppressor or Checkuser permissions.
 * Omnibus: A case about misconduct in a topic area writ large.
 * Other: Any case that doesn't fall into one of the categories above.


 * Scope: The overall scope of the case.
 * CT?: An indication of whether or not a case includes or included a discretionary sanctions or contentious topic remedy.
 * Remedy name: The name of the remedy (or a description of it, for earlier cases which did not have sectioned remedies).
 * Remedy (in modern terms): Basically my best attempt to explain, in plain English and modern understanding, what the remedy means.
 * If this section has a coloured background, the colour indicates its status or origin:
 * Yellow (#FFFF00) is a temporary injunction issued mid-case.
 * Blue (#00BFFF) is a post-close amendment or motion.
 * Red (#CD5C5C) is a remedy that has since been rescinded or otherwise is wholly reliant on previous remedies that are themselves rescinded.
 * Green (#32CD32) is a remedy whose wording was amended post-close, either due to an amendment/motion or due to changes in process (such as Discretionary Sanctions to Contentious Topic).
 * Brown (#D2691E) is suspended or in abeyence, usually as part of a period where a remedy has been appealed.


 * Amended/Enacted: If a remedy was added or amended post-close, this will be the calendar date (in UTC) when the remedy was modified or took effect.
 * Rescinded: If a remedy was terminated, this will be the calendar date (in UTC) when the remedy was ended.
 * Enforceable?: Indicates whether a given remedy can be invoked at WP:AE. Any remedy that predates April 2006 and was not still in force by then predates AE entirely.
 * Sup/Opp/Abs/Rcs: The vote totals for a remedy (Support, Oppose, Abstain, Recused).

Any case that has been courtesy-blanked or closed without action will be given a very brief description and nothing further.

Ireland article names

 * Decided: Jan. 04, 2009
 * Abbrev.: IAN
 * Type: Dispute
 * Scope: Intractible dispute over naming conventions for articles related to Ireland
 * CT?: No

G.-M. Cupertino

 * Decided: Jan. 16, 2009
 * Abbrev.: GMC
 * Type: Editor
 * Scope: G.-M Cupertino's sockpuppetry and gross incivility
 * CT?: No

Franco-Mongol alliance review/PHG

 * Decided: Feb. 02, 2009
 * Abbrev.: PHG
 * Type: Other
 * Scope: Review of FMA
 * CT?: No

Fringe science

 * Decided: Feb. 25, 2009
 * Abbrev.: FS
 * Type: Editor
 * Scope: ScienceApologist's aggressive behaviour in the fringe science topic area
 * CT?: No

SemBubenny

 * Decided: Mar. 04, 2009
 * Abbrev.: SBb
 * Type: Admin
 * Scope: SemBubenny's questionable speedy deletions
 * CT?: No

Ayn Rand

 * Decided: Mar. 15, 2009
 * Abbrev.: AR
 * Type: Dispute
 * Scope: Factionalism in the topic area of a specific eminent 20th-century philosopher.
 * CT?: Oct. 27, 2011 - Nov. 30, 2014 (motion)

MZMcBride

 * Decided: Apr. 08, 2009
 * Abbrev.: MZM
 * Type: Admin
 * Scope: MZMcBride's misuse of administrator tools and automation
 * CT?: No

Prem Rawat 2
(All hard remedies in this case were dependent on the article probation and so any still in effect were thus effectively rescinded and replaced with identical discretionary sanctions when that was replaced with a contentious topic designation on Dec. 20, 2012; this case's enforcement provision was struck when that motion passed.)


 * Decided: Apr. 20, 2009
 * Abbrev.: PR2
 * Type: Dispute
 * Scope: Continued issues in the Prem Rawat topic area after PR
 * CT?: No

West Bank - Judea and Samaria/Palestine-Israel articles 2

 * Decided: May 12, 2009
 * Abbrev.: PIA2
 * Type: Omnibus
 * Scope: Large-scale continued dispute in the PIA area disguised by a naming dispute over the West Bank region
 * CT?: No

Aitias

 * Decided: May 18, 2009
 * Abbrev.: AIT
 * Type: Admin
 * Scope: Aitias' poor judgment in granting rollback
 * CT?: No

Abd and JzG

 * Decided: May 18, 2009
 * Abbrev.: A-J
 * Type: Dispute/Admin
 * Scope: JzG's inappropriate tool use and Abd's abuse of dispute resolution
 * CT?: No

Ryulong

 * Decided: May 24, 2009
 * Abbrev.: RL
 * Type: Dispute
 * Scope: Ryulong and Mythdon's interactions with each other and WP:WikiProject Tokusatsu
 * CT?: No

Scientology

 * Decided: May 28, 2009
 * Abbrev.: SCI
 * Type: Omnibus
 * Scope: Extreme conflict-of-interest ownership of the Scientology topic area
 * CT?: June 01, 2012 - Feb. 02, 2022 (Motion)

(The remedies below refer to "the SCI area", which refers to any and all articles, edits, and discussions about Scientology and its adherents, broadly construed.)

Macedonia 2

 * Decided: June 11, 2009
 * Abbrev.: MAC2
 * Type: Dispute
 * Scope: Dispute over how what is now Northern Macedonia should be named/titled in articles
 * CT?: No

Tang Dynasty

 * Decided: June 11, 2009
 * Abbrev.: TANG
 * Type: Editor
 * Scope: Tenmei's conduct on the Tang Dynasty in Inner Asia article
 * CT?: No

Date de-linking

 * Decided: June 14, 2009
 * Abbrev.: DDL
 * Type: Dispute
 * Scope: Edit-warring over linking or de-linking dates in articles
 * CT?: No

(Unless explicitly stated otherwise, any remedy amended in this case was amended by Scope of topic bans and other restrictions, which narrowed the relevant topic-bans' scope to discussions and guidelines about (de-)linking dates and reverting edits that did such.)

Obama articles

 * Decided: June 21, 2009
 * Abbrev.: OA
 * Type: Dispute
 * Scope: Conduct of editors in the Barack Obama topic area
 * CT?: No

(Unless explicitly stated otherwise, any remedy amended in this case was amended by Amendment (July 2009) which limited the scope of the 1RR/week and justification requirements to the Barack Obama topic area.)

Seeyou

 * Decided: June 26, 2009
 * Abbrev.: SEE
 * Type: Editor
 * Scope: Seeyou's attempts at weaponising dispute resolution and bludgeoning debates
 * CT?: No

(This is the first case to use the modern "Arbitration/Requests/Case/ " naming convention.)

Mattisse

 * Decided: July 01, 2009
 * Abbrev.: MTS
 * Type: Editor
 * Scope: Mattisse's incivility
 * CT?: No

(All motions in this case were passed on December 15, 2009 as part of a suite of mentorship-related motions for the case. Their date will not be given for brevity.)

A Man In Black

 * Decided: June 30, 2009
 * Abbrev.: AMiB
 * Type: Editor
 * Scope: A Man In Black's constant edit-warring and campaign against Ikip
 * CT?: No

ADHD

 * Decided: July 14, 2009
 * Abbrev.: ADHD
 * Type: Omnibus
 * Scope: Behavioural disputes in the Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (hence "ADHD") topic area sparked by a AN thread requesting sanctions on Scuro
 * CT?: No

194x144x90x118
(The case is named for a registered user whose name resembles an IPv4 address; as such the name will not be expurgated.)


 * Decided: Sep. 10, 2009
 * Abbrev.: 194x
 * Type: Editor
 * Scope: 194x144x90x118's rampant incivility
 * CT?: No

Abd-William M. Connolley/Cold fusion 2
(The case name was changed on Mar. 21, 2012 per a Arbitration motion, but the motion was not appended to the case.)


 * Decided: Sep. 13, 2009
 * Abbrev.: CF2
 * Type: Dispute
 * Scope: Abd and William M. Connolley's disputes over cold fusion
 * CT?: Close - Nov. 30, 2014

(One post-case motion that updates the contentious topic designation will be omitted for brevity.)

Noloop

 * Closed: Oct. 04, 2009

(Closed with no substantial action due to both parties being indisposed - one went on extended wikibreak and the other was indefinitely blocked for an unrelated incident.)

Lapsed Pacifist 2

 * Decided: Oct. 12, 2009
 * Abbrev.: LP2
 * Type: Editor
 * Scope: Lapsed Pacifist's POV-pushing in the Corrib gas controversy topic area
 * CT?: No

Speed of light

 * Decided: Oct. 20, 2009
 * Abbrev.: SL
 * Type: Dispute
 * Scope: Brews ohare's and David Tombe's edit-warring over physics-related articles
 * CT?: No

Socionics

 * Decided: Dec. 12, 2009
 * Abbrev.: SOC
 * Type: Dispute
 * Scope: Rmcnew and Tcaudilllg's interactions on Socionics
 * CT?: No

Asmahan

 * Decided: Dec. 14, 2009
 * Abbrev.: ASM
 * Type: Dispute
 * Scope: Disputes over the nationality and ethnicity of various Middle-Eastern people
 * CT?: No

Ottava Rima's community-levied civility restrictions

 * Decided: Dec. 20, 2009
 * Abbrev.: ORR
 * Type: Other
 * Scope: User:Ottava Rima appealing restrictions placed on him by the community. Poorly.
 * CT?: No

Eastern Europe mailing-list collusion

 * Decided: Dec. 22, 2009
 * Abbrev.: EEML
 * Type: Omnibus
 * Scope: Addressing the existence of an off-wiki mailing list used to collude in the EE area
 * CT?: No

=Footnotes=