User:Jaditol/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Talk:Beef noodle soup - Wikipedia

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
The beef noodle soup is something that I have always been craving for after I studies abroad, especially during the cold winter with a hot soup. There aren't too much beef noodle soup that is tasted traditional in the greater Seattle Area. As looking through the page, I found there are something important missing or could elaborate more about the noodle style (thickness and ingredient) that I would like to contribute to. I personally want to know more history and information about the noodle style, as well as acknowledge readers that share the same interest with me on noodles.

Evaluate the article
Lead section: The lead section covers the basic information about beef noodle soup by providing plenty of external information that readers will be able to click on. It might be better if the information are listed explicitly to make readers easier to read.

Content: There are lots of room to improve with more detailed and engaging information, and some of them are not up-to-date.

Tone and balance: The tone is natural, but still can be improved.

Source and reference: More sources should be better to prove and make a more solid information page.

Organization and writing quality: The quality is fair and covers the basics. The organization structure is simple and should be more well-organized.

Images and media: The pictures shown are fairly great quality and good amount, but could be improved by more attractive pictures.

Take page section: The talk page section has lots of information that can be collaborate to the main article section.

Over impression: The overall status is stub which has a fairly large space to improve, the length aren't that long for food and definitely has room to improve.