User:Jadrzd/Tan Yunxian

Peer review responses

I will be sure to review my grammar and correct it when needed. Hyperlinks will be added where possible to important subtopics readers may want more information on. There are a few sentences I need to add citations at the end of. This review on my partner's draft mentions adding more information about Tan's life, which I have done in my article.

Though not mentioned in the peer reviews, I am considering adding more info on the book about Tan in the popular portrayals section.

Life[edit]
Tan's grandmother was the daughter of a physician. One reason Tan's grandfather married her grandmother was to learn medicine himself. Two of her grandparents' sons, including Tan's father, were able to pass the jinshi examinations, and they became officials. Due to the fondness her grandparents had for her, which evidence shows was directly related to her intellect, her grandparents passed on their medical knowledge to her. Tan's grandmother left Tan her medical manuals and tools upon her deathbed. However, she did not start implementing this knowledge until she herself became ill.

Tan Yunxian later married, raised four children, and practiced medicine on women. '''Out of these four children, two were sons. Both of these sons tragically passed at a young age, ending her family line.''' Tan lived a longer life than most, dying at the age of 93.

Medical activity[edit]
Tan Yunxian's medical practice was contained to treating women. She initially began by treating her own children, with her grandmother's guidance to confirm her diagnoses. She is known to diagnosis herself and others of her family and compare that diagnosis to that of the outside doctor. She would then collect his prescriptions and pick and choose ingredients at her discretion to better treat the ailment. Records of Tan's book reveal cases of thirty-one of the patients that she treated. The women she worked with usually had chronic complaints, rather than of temporary illnesses. Many of these women had “women’s complaints,” such as menstrual irregularities, repeated miscarriages, barrenness, and postpartum fatigue. Other patients had illnesses that either sex could contract, such as coughing, insomnia, rashes, swellings, diarrhea or nausea.

Tan, similar to other literati doctors, often prescribed herbal medications to her patients. She also practiced moxibustion. This was the burning of moxa, or dried Artemisia, at specified points on the body, which was similar to acupuncture. This process was believed to stimulate the circulation of qi. Since the physician applying the moxa had to physically touch the patient, male doctors were unable to perform this treatment on women. Tan served many working women in her practice. Various accounts show Tan's conclusions that these women often overworked themselves, whether physically or mentally, thus bringing on various symptoms.

Although Tan Yunxian was able to practice gynecology, pediatrics and obstetrics, her experience in other fields was limited. Tan was only able to practice medicine in the country among her friends or acquaintances. Even after she completed the book Sayings of a Female Doctor, the only physician book written by a woman in the Ming Dynasty, she was not able to publish it. In fact, she had to ask her son to have printing blocks cut for her. In the prologue of her book, Tan frets about its reception due to her being a female author. She says "I beg readers' indulgence and ask that they do not laugh at me."

Status of female physicians in Ming China[edit]
Quite different from their male counterparts of ancient China, women did not hone their skills by studying with masters nor did they have the purpose or goal in mind to set up their own clinics after their apprenticeship. For females, family training was the standard mode of education. While women were quite skilled in their medical techniques, they rarely made any theoretical additions to the field. Unlike the male doctors of the times, women received medical training in order to assist the males in their family by doing some “supporting work.” After practicing medicine it is said that "she always get wonderful therapeutic effects in treating those females who refuse to see a male physician". Women in Ming China could not ask their male doctors about certain medical conditions.

'''Male doctors were often not allowed to physically touch women due to issues of propriety and gender norms. A male doctor could not touch a woman during an examination, but rather had to review her symptoms through asking her questions or using a male relative or husband as a go-between. This caused additional issues in cases such as bone setting where physical touch is required. '''

'''However, not all parts of the female body were prohibited from the touch of a doctor, such as the head. Propriety also depended upon the age of the woman; older women past childbearing age and young children were exempted from many physical boundaries, but women of marrying age were treated with extra propriety. '''

Popular portrayal[edit]
A character that combines Tan with Jingtai Emperor consort Empress Hang was portrayed by Cecilia Liu in 2016 Chinese historical drama series The Imperial Doctress. In that series, the character's surname was changed from 談 to the homophone surname 譚. '''The series focuses on a fictionalized love triangle between Tan and two emperors, with her medical work becoming a side plot. The series' lavish yet historically accurate costumes are reported to cost over $460,000 USD. '''

Tan is the main character of Lisa See's 2023 novel Lady Tan's Circle of Women (ISBN 1982117087). The novel focuses on the personal life of Tan, beginning with her education from her grandmother and through her struggles as a female physician in the Ming Dynasty. The novel also focuses on her friendship with a midwife, and the stigmas surrounding this friendship at the time.