User:Jan eissfeldt/x

See Ambassadors/Steering Committee/2011-05-06 for backround


 * uni-focus-version:

merger of the university-part of SUP with Ambassadors/Courses and establish School projects under the roof of the WikiProject Classroom coordination. a joint page Educational assignments could ensure an overview and delegate the user in the direction, he is interested in


 * pros:


 * clear structures
 * reflects different learning environment in school/higher education
 * gets rid of some redundant on wiki-structures
 * can prearrange the system for the more global approach regarding a higher volume of school project output


 * contras


 * the school projects/ambassador projects in higher education aren't defined and (often) not factual on the ground


 * the ambassador projects, which are likely to take place on en.wp, are structured along the national lines of wikimedia chapter structures and that neither recommends a single page regarding transparency and responsibility nor the different circumstances on the ground


 * joint version:

WP:SUP simply integrates the established Ambassadors/Courses-list via template


 * pros:


 * a joint page for all practical educational outreach activities, that provide base informations regarding all possible processes, would be maintained
 * no need for re-structuring of the wikipedia name space


 * contras:


 * it's unclear whether or not the established ambassador structures would have to move to a US-specific WPNS-lemma
 * doesn't reflect qualitative differences regarding community support
 * doesn't reflect the progress we made between 2009 and 2011