User:Jasmiiinee/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Spotify Wrapped

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I really love seeing everybody's Spotify Wrapped's at the end of the year so I picked this article.

Evaluate the article
Lead Section: The lead section to me seems great. It explains what a Spotify Wrapped is and does it well. It also describes the marketing and overall hype about it without giving too much detail. The only thing I have a small problem with is that in the lead section it talks about marking and then continues into the next section about the purpose and also talks about more marketing. Though it's brief, I think it would make more sense to move that into the Purpose section.

Content: The content is good, it's laid out like a very thorough research paper. It goes in detail about every single aspect of Spotify Wrapped and then talks about the people involved and the different criticisms.

Tone and Balance: I think that this article has a very neutral tone. There's no bias towards Spotify or any other music streaming platform. It's all fairly neutral, talks about the hype and interest along with criticisms.

Sources: Every fact that was listed seemed to be backed up by links to another Wikipedia page or was cited at the bottom of the page.

Organization: I think that the way the sections are ordered make perfect sense to the topic of the Wikipedia page. Everything was clear and made sense to me. It starts with Spotify and ends with how Spotify Wrapped extended from itself and influenced a lot of other things.

Images: There's only one image and it's from 2020 and does not help the reader understand what a Spotify Wrapped is at all. To somebody that has never seen a Spotify Wrapped they wouldn't be able to picture it with that photo so I think example photos from recent Spotify Wrapped's would enhance this article by a lot.

Talk Page: The talk page is just other people correcting small mistakes made by other writers. The talk page can be very helpful when deciding to add or correct something in an article because other people who may know more than you can give you input and be a second pair of eyes to your addition.

Overall Impressions: I really liked reading this Wikipedia page. Not only was it fun to read something that I know about and am familiar with, it was fun to see other people more passionate than me in the talk page. I think the main issue I had was just the lack of photo's within the article. Spotify Wrapped is meant to be something fun, exciting, and colorful and none of that is translated in the article.