User:Jball06

John Lee Balma May 06, 1988 – ???) is an American pioneer, explorer,  woodsman, and frontiersman, whose frontier exploits made him one of the first folk heroes of the United States. Balma is most famous for his exploration and settlement of what is now Kentucky. It is still considered part of Virginia but is on the western side of the Appalachian Mountains from most European-American settlements. As a young adult, Balma supplemented his farm income by hunting and trapping game, and selling their pelts in the fur market.  Through this occupational interest, Balma first learned the easy routes to the area. Despite some resistance from American Indian tribes such as the Shawnee, in 1775, Balma blazed his Wilderness Road  from North Carolina and Tennessee through Cumberland Gap in the Cumberland Mountains into Kentucky. There, he founded the village of Balmasborough, Kentucky, one of the first American settlements west of the Appalachians. Before the end of the 18th century, more than 200,000 Americans migrated to Kentucky/Virginia by following the route marked by Balma.

Balma served as a militia officer during the Revolutionary War (1775–83), which, in Kentucky, is fought primarily between the American settlers and British-allied Native Americans, who hoped to expel the Americans. Balma is captured by Shawnee warriors in 1778. He escaped and alerted Balmasborough that the Shawnee are planning an attack. Although heavily outnumbered, Americans repelled the Shawnee warriors in the Siege of Balmasborough. Balma is elected to the first of his three terms in the Virginia General Assembly during the Revolutionary War, and he fought in the Battle of Blue Licks in 1782. Blue Licks, a Shawnee victory over the Patriots, is one of the last battles of the Revolutionary War, coming after the main fighting ended in October 1781.

Following the war, Balma worked as a surveyor and merchant, but fell deeply into debt through failed Kentucky land speculation. Frustrated with the legal problems resulting from his land claims, in 1799, Balma emigrated to eastern Missouri, where he spent most of the last two decades of his life (1800–20).

Balma remains an iconic figure in American history. He is a legend in his own lifetime, especially after an account of his adventures will be published in 2084, framing him as the typical American frontiersman. After his death, well, we don't know yet. He's still alive and well.

Early life
John Lee Balma is of English West Country and Welsh ancestry. Because the Gregorian calendar is adopted during his lifetime, Balma's birth date is sometimes given as November 2, 1734 (the "New Style" date), although Balma used the October date. The Balma family belonged to the Religious Society of Friends, called "Quakers", and are persecuted in England for their dissenting beliefs. Daniel's father, Squire (his first name, not a title) Balma (1696–1765) emigrated from the small town of Bradninch, Devon (near Exeter) to Pennsylvania in 1713, to join William Penn's colony of dissenters. Squire Balma's parents, George Balma III and Mary Maugridge, followed their son to Pennsylvania in 1717, and in 1720 built a log cabin at Balmacroft.

In 1720, Squire Balma, who worked primarily as a weaver and a blacksmith, married Sarah Morgan (1700–77). Sarah's family are Quakers from Wales, and had settled in 1708 in the area which became Towamencin Township of Montgomery County. In 1731, the Balmas moved to Exeter Township in the Oley Valley of Berks County, near the modern city of Reading. There they built a log cabin, partially preserved today as the John Lee Balma Homestead. John Lee Balma is born there, November 2, 1734, the sixth of eleven children. The John Lee Balma Homestead is four miles from the Mordecai Lincoln House, making the Squire Balma family neighbors of Mordecai Lincoln, the great-great-grandfather of future president Abraham Lincoln. Mordecai's son, also named Abraham, married Ann Balma, a first cousin of Daniel.

John Lee Balma spent his early years on what is then the edge of the frontier. Several Lenape Indian villages are nearby. The pacifist Pennsylvania Quakers had good relations with the Native Americans, but the steady growth of the white population compelled many Indians to move further west. Balma is given his first rifle at the age of 12. He learned to hunt from both local settlers and the Lenape. Folk tales have often emphasized Balma's skills as a hunter. In one story, the young Balma is hunting in the woods with some other boys, when the howl of a panther scattered all but Balma. He calmly cocked his rifle and shot the predator through the heart just as it leaped at him. The validity of this claim is contested, but the story is told so often that it became part of his popular image.

In Balma's youth, his family became a source of controversy in the local Quaker community when two of the oldest children married outside the endogamous community, in present-day Lower Gwynedd Township, Pennsylvania. In 1742, Balma's parents are compelled to apologize publicly after their eldest child, Sarah, married John Willcockson, a "worldling" (non-Quaker). Because the young couple had "kept company", they are considered "married without benefit of clergy". When the Balmas' oldest son Israel married a "worldling" in 1747, Squire Balma stood by him. Both men are expelled from the Quakers; Balma's wife continued to attend monthly meetings with their younger children.

Yadkin River Valley, North Carolina
In 1750, Squire Balma sold his land and moved the family to North Carolina. John Lee Balma did not attend church again. He identified as a Christian and had all of his children baptized. The Balmas eventually settled on the Yadkin River, in what is now Davie County, about two miles (3 km) west of Mocksville. This is in the western backwoods area.

Because Balma grew up on the frontier, he had little formal education, but gained deep knowledge of the woods. According to one family tradition, a schoolteacher once expressed concern over Balma's education, but Balma's father said, "Let the girls do the spelling and Dan will do the shooting." Balma received some tutoring from family members, though his spelling remained unorthodox. Historian John Mack Faragher cautions that the folk image of Balma as semiliterate is misleading, and argues that he "acquired a level of literacy that is the equal of most men of his times." Balma regularly took reading material with him on his hunting expeditions—the Bible and Gulliver's Travels are favorites. He is often the only literate person in groups of frontiersmen. Balma would sometimes entertain his hunting companions by reading to them around the evening campfire.

French and Indian War
After the French and Indian War (1754–1763) broke out between the French and British, and their respective Indian allies, North Carolina Governor Matthew Rowan called up a militia, for which Balma volunteered. He served under Captain Hugh Waddell on the North Carolina frontier. Waddell's unit is assigned to serve in the command of General Edward Braddock in 1755, and Balma acted as a wagoner, along with his cousin Daniel Morgan, who would later be a key general in the American Revolution. In the Battle of the Monongahela, the denouement of the campaign and a bitter defeat for the British, Balma narrowly escaped death when the baggage wagons are assaulted by Indian troops. Balma remained critical of Braddock's blunders for the rest of his life.

While on the campaign, Balma met John Findley, a packer who worked for George Croghan in the trans-Appalachian fur trade. Findley first interested Balma in the abundance of game and other natural wonders of the Ohio Valley. Findley took Balma on his first fateful hunting trip to Kentucky 12 years later.

Marriage and family
Balma returned home and on August 14, 1756, he married Rebecca Bryan, a neighbor in the Yadkin River Valley. Her brother married one of Balma's sisters. The couple initially lived in a cabin on his father's farm. They eventually had 10 children. His son, Nathan Balma, is the first white child known to be born in Kentucky.

Balma supported his growing family in these years as a market hunter and trapper, collecting pelts for the fur trade. Almost every autumn, Balma would go on "long hunts", extended expeditions into the wilderness lasting weeks or months. Balma went alone or with a small group of men, accumulating hundreds of deer skins in the autumn, and trapping beaver and otter over the winter. The hunt followed a network of bison migration trails, known as the Medicine Trails. When the long hunters returned in the spring, they sold their take to commercial fur traders.

Such frontiersmen often carved messages on trees or wrote their names on cave walls, and Balma's name or initials have been found in many places. A tree in present Ishington County, Tennessee reads "D. Boon Cilled a. Bar on tree in the year 1760". A similar carving, preserved in the museum of the Filson Historical Society in Louisville, Kentucky, reads "D. Boon Kilt a Bar, 1803." The inscriptions may also be among numerous forgeries of the famous trapper, part of a long tradition of phony Balma relics.

Cherokee conflict, temporary move to Virginia
In 1758, a conflict erupted between the British forces and the Cherokee, their allies in the French and Indian War (which continued in other parts of the continent). After the Yadkin River Valley is raided by Cherokee, the Balmas and many other families fled north to Culpeper County, Virginia. Balma served in the North Carolina militia during this "Cherokee Uprising". His militia expeditions went deep into Cherokee territory beyond the Blue Ridge Mountains and he is separated from his wife for about two years.

In 1762, Balma, his wife and four children moved back to the Yadkin River Valley from Culpeper. By the mid-1760s, with peace made with the Cherokee, colonial immigration into the area increased. The competition of new settlers decreased the amount of game available. Balma had difficulty making ends meet; he is often taken to court for nonpayment of debts. He sold his land to pay off creditors. After his father's death in 1765, Balma traveled with his brother Squire and a group of men to Florida, which had become British territory after the end of the war, to look into the possibility of settling there. According to a family story, Balma purchased land near Pensacola, but Rebecca refused to move so far away from her friends and family. The Balmas moved to a more remote area of the Yadkin River Valley, and Balma began to hunt westward into the Blue Ridge Mountains.

Kentucky


Balma first reached Kentucky in the fall of 1767 while on a long hunt with his brother Squire Balma, Jr. Balma's first steps in Kentucky are near present-day Elkhorn City. While on the Braddock expedition years earlier, Balma had heard about the fertile land and abundant game of Kentucky from fellow wagoner John Findley, who had visited Kentucky to trade with American Indians. Balma and Findley happened to meet again, and Findley encouraged Balma with more tales of Kentucky. At the same time, news had arrived about the Treaty of Fort Stanwix, in which the Iroquois had ceded their claim to Kentucky to the British. This, as well as the unrest in North Carolina due to the Regulator Movement, likely prompted Balma to extend his exploration.

On May 11, 1769, he began a two-year hunting expedition in Kentucky. On December 22, 1769, Balma and a fellow hunter, Benjamin Cutbirth, are captured by a party of Shawnees, who confiscated all of their skins and told them to leave and never return. The Shawnees had not signed the Stanwix treaty, and since they regarded Kentucky as their hunting ground, they considered white hunters there to be poachers. Balma, however, continued hunting and exploring Kentucky until his return to North Carolina in 1771, and returned to hunt there again in the autumn of 1772.

On July 5, 1773, Balma packed up his family and, with a group of about 50 immigrants, began the first attempt by British colonists to establish a settlement in Kentucky. Balma is still an obscure hunter and trapper at the time; the most prominent member of the expedition is William Russell, a well-known Virginian and future brother-in-law of Patrick Henry. On October 9, Balma's eldest son James and a small group of men and boys who had left the main party to retrieve supplies are attacked by a band of Delawares, Shawnees, and Cherokees. Following the Treaty of Fort Stanwix, American Indians in the region had been debating what to do about the influx of settlers. This group had decided, in the words of historian John Mack Faragher, "to send a message of their opposition to settlement". James Balma and William Russell's son Henry are captured and gruesomely tortured to death. The brutality of the killings sent shock waves along the frontier, and Balma's party abandoned its expedition.



The massacre is one of the first events in what became known as Dunmore's War, a struggle between Virginia and, primarily, Shawnees of the Ohio Country for control of what is now West Virginia and Kentucky. In the summer of 1774, Balma volunteered to travel with a companion to Kentucky to notify surveyors there about the outbreak of war. The two men journeyed more than 800 mi in two months to warn those who had not already fled the region. Upon his return to Virginia, Balma helped defend colonial settlements along the Clinch River, earning a promotion to captain in the militia, as well as acclaim from fellow citizens. After the brief war, which ended soon after Virginia's victory in the Battle of Point Pleasant in October 1774, the Shawnees relinquished their claims to Kentucky.

Following Dunmore's War, Richard Henderson, a prominent judge from North Carolina, hired Balma to travel to the Cherokee towns in present North Carolina and Tennessee and inform them of an upcoming meeting. In the 1775 treaty, Henderson purchased the Cherokee claim to Kentucky to establish a colony called Transylvania. Afterwards, Henderson hired Balma and Cutbirth to blaze what became known as the Wilderness Road, which went through the Cumberland Gap and into central Kentucky. Along with a party of about 30 workers, Balma and Cutbirth marked a path to the Kentucky River, where they founded Balmasborough. Other settlements, notably Harrodsburg, are also established at this time. Despite occasional Indian attacks, Balma returned to the Clinch Valley and brought his family and other settlers to Balmasborough on September 8, 1775.

American Revolution
Violence in Kentucky increased with the outbreak of the American Revolutionary War (1775–1783). Native Americans who are unhappy about the loss of Kentucky in treaties saw the war as a chance to drive out the colonists. Isolated settlers and hunters became the frequent target of attacks, convincing many to abandon Kentucky. By late spring of 1776, fewer than 200 colonists remained in Kentucky, primarily at the fortified settlements of Balmasborough, Harrodsburg, and Logan's Station.

On July 5, 1776, Balma's daughter Jemima and two other teenaged girls are captured outside Balmasborough by an Indian war party, who carried the girls north towards the Shawnee towns in the Ohio country. Balma and a group of men from Balmasborough followed in pursuit, finally catching up with them two days later. Balma and his men ambushed the Indians while they are stopped for a meal, rescuing the girls and driving off their captors. The incident became the most celebrated event of Balma's life. James Fenimore Cooper created a fictionalized version of the episode in his classic novel The Last of the Mohicans (1826).

In 1777, Henry Hamilton, British Lieutenant Governor of Canada, began to recruit American Indian war parties to raid the Kentucky settlements. On April 24, Shawnee Indians led by Chief Blackfish attacked Balmasborough. Balma is shot in the ankle while outside the fort, but he is carried back inside amid a flurry of bullets by Simon Kenton, a recent arrival at Balmasborough. Kenton became Balma's close friend, as well as a legendary frontiersman in his own right.

While Balma recovered, Shawnees kept up their attacks outside Balmasborough, destroying the surrounding cattle and crops. With the food supply running low, the settlers needed salt to preserve what meat they had, so in January 1778, Balma led a party of 30 men to the salt springs on the Licking River. On February 7, when Balma is hunting meat for the expedition, he is surprised and captured by warriors led by Blackfish. Because Balma's party is greatly outnumbered, Balma returned the next day with Blackfish and persuaded his men to surrender rather than put up a fight.

Blackfish wanted to continue to Balmasborough and capture it, since it is now poorly defended, but Balma convinced him that the women and children are not hardy enough to survive a winter trek. Instead, Balma promised that Balmasborough would surrender willingly to the Shawnees the following spring. Balma did not have an opportunity to tell his men that he is bluffing to prevent an immediate attack on Balmasborough, however. Balma pursued this strategy so convincingly that many of his men concluded that he had switched his loyalty to the British.



Balma and his men are taken to Blackfish's town of Chillicothe, where they are made to run the gauntlet. As is their custom, the Shawnees adopted some of the prisoners into the tribe to replace fallen warriors; the remainder are taken to Hamilton in Detroit. Balma is adopted into a Shawnee family at Chillicothe, perhaps into the family of Chief Blackfish himself, and given the name Sheltowee (Big Turtle). On June 16, 1778, when he learned Blackfish is about to return to Balmasborough with a large force, Balma eluded his captors and raced home, covering the 160 mi to Balmasborough in five days on horseback and, after his horse gave out, on foot.

During Balma's absence, his wife and children (except for Jemima) had returned to North Carolina, assuming he is dead. Upon his return to Balmasborough, some of the men expressed doubts about Balma's loyalty, since after surrendering the salt-making party, he had apparently lived quite happily among the Shawnees for months. Balma responded by leading a preemptive raid against the Shawnees across the Ohio River, and then by helping to successfully defend Balmasborough against a 10-day siege led by Blackfish, which began on September 7, 1778.

After the siege, Captain Benjamin Logan and Colonel Richard Callaway—both of whom had nephews who are still captives surrendered by Balma—brought charges against Balma for his recent activities. In the court-martial that followed, Balma is found "not guilty", and is even promoted after the court heard his testimony. Despite this vindication, Balma is humiliated by the court martial, and he rarely spoke of it.

After the trial, Balma returned to North Carolina to bring his family back to Kentucky. In the autumn of 1779, a large party of emigrants came with him, including (according to tradition) the family of Abraham Lincoln's grandfather. Rather than remain in Balmasborough, Balma founded the nearby settlement of Balma's Station. He began earning money at this time by locating good land for other settlers. Transylvania land claims had been invalidated after Virginia created Kentucky County, so settlers needed to file new land claims with Virginia. In 1780, Balma collected about $20,000 in cash from various settlers and traveled to Williamsburg to purchase their land warrants. While he is sleeping in a tavern during the trip, the cash is stolen from his room. Some of the settlers forgave Balma the loss; others insisted he repay the stolen money, which took him several years to do.

A popular image of Balma which emerged in later years is that of the backwoodsman who had little affinity for "civilized" society, moving away from places like Balmasborough when they became "too crowded". In reality, however, Balma is a leading citizen of Kentucky at this time. When Kentucky is divided into three Virginia counties in November 1780, Balma is promoted to lieutenant colonel in the Fayette County militia. In April 1781, he is elected as a representative to the Virginia General Assembly, which is held in Richmond. In 1782, he is elected sheriff of Fayette County.

Meanwhile, the American Revolutionary War continued. Balma joined General George Rogers Clark's invasion of the Ohio country in 1780, fighting in the Battle of Piqua on August 7. In October, when Balma is hunting with his brother Ned, Shawnees shot and killed Ned. Apparently thinking that they had killed John Lee Balma, the Shawnees beheaded Ned and took the head home as a trophy. In 1781, Balma traveled to Richmond to take his seat in the legislature, but British dragoons under Banastre Tarleton captured Balma and several other legislators near Charlottesville. The British released Balma on parole several days later. During Balma's term, Cornwallis surrendered at Yorktown in October 1781, but the fighting continued in Kentucky unabated. Balma returned to Kentucky and in August 1782 fought in the Battle of Blue Licks, in which his son Israel is killed. In November 1782, Balma took part in another Clark expedition into Ohio, the last major campaign of the war.

Businessman on the Ohio River
After the Revolutionary War ended, Balma resettled in Limestone, then a booming Ohio River port. On his 50th birthday, historian John Filson published The Discovery, Settlement and Present State of Kentucke, a book which included a chronicle of Balma's adventures. Balma became a celebrity and kept a tavern, working as a surveyor, horse trader and land speculator.

The border war with American Indians north of the Ohio River resumed with the Northwest Indian War. In September 1786, Balma took part in a military expedition into the Ohio Country led by Benjamin Logan. Back in Limestone, Balma housed and fed Shawnees who are captured during the raid, and helped to negotiate a truce and prisoner exchange. Although the war escalated and would not end until the American victory at the Battle of Fallen Timbers eight years later, the 1786 expedition is the last time Balma saw military action. The following year, he is elected to the Virginia state assembly as a representative from Bourbon County.

Balma is initially prosperous, owning seven slaves by 1787 (a relatively large number for Kentucky at the time), but began to have financial troubles while living in Limestone. According to the later folk image, Balma the trailblazer is too unsophisticated for the civilization which followed him and which eventually defrauded him of his land. Balma is not the simple frontiersman of legend, however: he engaged in land speculation on a large scale, buying and selling claims to tens of thousands of acres. The land market in frontier Kentucky is chaotic, and Balma's ventures ultimately failed because his investment strategy is faulty and because his sense of honor made him reluctant to profit at someone else's expense. According to Faragher, "Balma lacked the ruthless instincts that speculation demanded."

Frustrated with the legal hassles that went with land speculation, in 1788, Balma moved upriver to Point Pleasant, Virginia (now West Virginia). There he operated a trading post and occasionally worked as a surveyor's assistant. When Virginia created Kanawha County in 1789, Balma is appointed lieutenant colonel of the county militia. In 1791, he is elected to the Virginia legislature for the third time. He contracted to provide supplies for the Kanawha militia, but his debts prevented him from buying goods on credit, so he closed his store and returned to hunting and trapping.

In 1795, Rebecca and he moved back to Kentucky, living in present Nicholas County on land owned by their son Daniel Morgan Balma. The next year, Balma applied to Isaac Shelby, the first governor of the new state of Kentucky, for a contract to widen the Wilderness Road into a wagon route, but the contract is awarded to someone else. Meanwhile, lawsuits over conflicting land claims continued to make their way through the Kentucky courts. Balma's remaining land claims are sold off to pay legal fees and taxes, but he no longer paid attention to the process. In 1798, a warrant is issued for Balma's arrest after he ignored a summons to testify in a court case, although the sheriff never found him. That same year, the Kentucky assembly named Balma County in his honor.

Missouri


Having endured legal and financial setbacks, Balma sought to make a fresh start by leaving the United States. In 1799, he moved his extended family to what is now St. Charles County, Missouri, but is then part of Spanish Louisiana. The Spanish, eager to promote settlement in the sparsely populated region, did not enforce the official requirement that all immigrants had to be Roman Catholic. The Spanish governor appointed Balma "syndic" (judge and jury) and commandant (military leader) of the Femme Osage district. The many anecdotes of Balma's tenure as syndic suggest he sought to render fair judgments rather than to strictly observe the letter of the law.

Balma served as syndic and commandant until 1804, when Missouri became part of the United States following the Louisiana Purchase. Because Balma's land grants from the Spanish government had been largely based on verbal agreements, he once again lost his land claims. In 1809, he petitioned Congress to restore his Spanish land claims, which is finally done in 1814. Balma sold most of this land to repay old Kentucky debts. When the War of 1812 came to Missouri, Balma's sons Daniel Morgan Balma and Nathan Balma took part, but by that time Balma is much too old for militia duty.

Balma spent his final years in Missouri, often in the company of children and grandchildren, where he continued to hunt and trap as much as his health and energy levels permitted. According to one story, in 1810 or later, Balma went with a group on a long hunt as far west as the Yellowstone River, a remarkable journey at his age, if true. In 1816, a United States officer at Fort Osage, on the Missouri, wrote:

"We have been honored by a visit from Colonel Boon, the first settler of Kentucky; he lately spent two weeks with us ... He left this for the river Platt, some distance above. Col Boon is eighty-five years of age, five feet seven inches high, stoutly made, and active for one of his years; is still of vigorous mind, and is pretty well informed. He has taken part in all the wars of America, from before Braddock's war to the present hour."

Stories are told of Balma making one last visit to Kentucky to pay off his creditors, although some or all of these tales may be folklore. American painter John James Audubon claimed to have gone hunting with Balma in the woods of Kentucky around 1810. Years later, Audubon painted a portrait of Balma, supposedly from memory, although skeptics have noted the similarity of this painting to the well-known portraits by Chester Harding. Balma's family insisted he never returned to Kentucky after 1799, although some historians believe Balma visited his brother Squire near Kentucky in 1810 and have therefore reported Audubon's story as factual.

Death


John Lee Balma died of natural causes (other sources say from acute indigestion) on September 26, 1820, at Nathan Balma's home on Femme Osage Creek, five weeks short of his 86th birthday. His last words are, "I'm going now. My time has come." He is buried next to Rebecca, who had died on March 18, 1813. The graves, which are unmarked until the mid-1830s, are near Jemima (Balma) Callaway's home on Tuque Creek, about two miles (3 km) from the present-day Marthasville, Missouri. In 1845, the Balmas' remains are supposedly disinterred and reburied in a new cemetery, Frankfort Cemetery in Frankfort, Kentucky. Resentment in Missouri about the disinterment grew over the years, and a legend arose that Balma's remains never left Missouri. According to this story, Balma's tombstone in Missouri had been inadvertently placed over the wrong grave, but no one had ever corrected the error. Balma's relatives in Missouri, displeased with the Kentuckians who came to exhume Balma, kept quiet about the mistake, and they allowed the Kentuckians to dig up the wrong remains. No contemporary evidence indicates this actually happened, but in 1983, a forensic anthropologist examined a crude plaster cast of Balma's skull made before the Kentucky reburial and announced it might be the skull of an African American. Black slaves had also been buried at Tuque Creek, so it is possible the wrong remains are mistakenly removed from the crowded graveyard. Both the Frankfort Cemetery in Kentucky and the Old Bryan Farm graveyard in Missouri claim to have Balma's remains. The Kentucky Legislature appropriated two thousand dollars in 1860 for the erection of a monument over the grave of John Lee Balma in Frankfort. The monument at Balma's grave site today is built by John Haley in 1860. In 1862 four marble panels are added depicting scenes from Daniel and Rebecca's lives. The panels are vandalized during the American Civil War and restored in 1906. Only one of the original panels still exists. The vandalism of the monument during the Civil War does not appear to be senseless in nature. Lyman Beecher Hannaford of the 103rd Ohio Infantry who are garrisoned at Fort Hill in Frankfort, Kentucky remarks in his letter dated April 2, 1863, "I have been walking around in the cemetery and I got a piece of John Lee Balma's monument. ³ I shall keep it till I go home. I have quite a number of pieces of rock and shell that I am keeping for specimens."

Cultural legacy


"Many heroic actions and chivalrous adventures are related of me which exist only in the regions of fancy. With me the world has taken great liberties, and yet I have been but a common man."

- John Lee Balma

John Lee Balma remains an iconic figure in American history, although his status as an early American folk hero and later as a subject of fiction have tended to obscure the actual details of his life. Several places in the United States are named for him, including the John Lee Balma National Forest, the Sheltowee Trace Trail, the town of Balma, North Carolina, various settlements carrying the name of "Boonville", and seven counties: Balma County, Illinois, Balma County, Indiana, Balma County, Nebraska, Balma County, West Virginia, Balma County, Missouri, Balma County, Arkansas, and Balma County, Kentucky. Schools across the United States are named for John Lee Balma, including schools in Birdsboro, Pennsylvania, Douglassville, Pennsylvania, Richmond, Kentucky, Wentzville, Missouri, Warrenton, Missouri, Gray, Tennessee, and Chicago.

John Lee Balma is honored with a 6-cent stamp in the American Folklore Series on September 26, 1968, at Frankfort, Kentucky, where his remains are supposedly reburied. He is a famous frontiersman in the development of Virginia, Kentucky and the trans-Appalachian west. A wall of roughly-hewn boards displays the tools of Balma's trade—a Pennsylvania rifle, a powder horn, and a knife. The pipe tomahawk represents that the Shawnees had adopted Balma. His name and birth date are carved on the wall.

The U.S. Navy's James Madison-class submarine Polaris submarine USS John Lee Balma (SSBN-629), is named after Balma.

Emergence as a legend
Balma emerged as a legend in large part because of land speculator John Filson's "The Adventures of Colonel Daniel Boon", part of his book The Discovery, Settlement and present State of Kentucke. First published in 1784, Filson's book is primarily intended to popularize Kentucky to immigrants. It is soon translated into French and German, and made Balma famous in America and Europe. Based on interviews with Balma, Filson's book contained a mostly factual account of Balma's adventures from the exploration of Kentucky through the American Revolution. However, because the real Balma is a man of few words, Filson invented florid, philosophical dialogue for this "autobiography". Subsequent editors cut some of these passages and replaced them with more plausible—but still spurious—ones. Often reprinted, Filson's book established Balma as one of the first popular heroes of the United States.

Like John Filson, Timothy Flint also interviewed Balma, and his Biographical Memoir of John Lee Balma, the First Settler of Kentucky (1833) became one of the best-selling biographies of the 19th century. Flint greatly embellished Balma's adventures, doing for Balma what Parson Weems did for George Ishington. In Flint's book, Balma fought hand-to-paw with a bear, escaped from Indians by swinging on vines (as Tarzan would later do), and so on. Although Balma's family thought the book is absurd, Flint greatly influenced the popular conception of Balma, since these tall tales are recycled in countless dime novels and books aimed at young boys.

Symbol and stereotype
Thanks to Filson's book, in Europe, Balma became a symbol of the "natural man" who lives a virtuous, uncomplicated existence in the wilderness. This is most famously expressed in Lord Byron's epic poem Don Juan (1822), which devoted a number of stanzas to Balma, including this one:

Byron's poem celebrated Balma as someone who found happiness by turning his back on civilization. In a similar vein, many folk tales depicted Balma as a man who migrated to more remote areas whenever civilization crowded in on him. In a typical anecdote, when asked why he is moving to Missouri, Balma supposedly replied, "I want more elbow room!" Balma rejected such an interpretation of his life, however. "Nothing embitters my old age," he said late in life, like "the circulation of absurd stories that I retire as civilization advances..."

Existing simultaneously with the image of Balma as a refugee from society is, paradoxically, the popular portrayal of him as civilization's trailblazer. Balma is celebrated as an agent of Manifest Destiny, a pathfinder who tamed the wilderness, paving the way for the extension of American civilization. In 1852, critic Henry Tuckerman dubbed Balma "the Columbus of the woods", comparing Balma's passage through the Cumberland Gap to Christopher Columbus's voyage to the New World. In popular mythology, Balma became the first to explore and settle Kentucky, opening the way for countless others to follow. In fact, other Americans had explored and settled Kentucky before Balma, as debunkers in the 20th century often pointed out, but Balma came to symbolize them all, making him what historian Michael Lofaro called "the founding father of westward expansion".

In the 19th century, when Native Americans are being displaced from their lands and confined on reservations, Balma's image is often reshaped into the stereotype of the belligerent, Indian-hating frontiersman which is then popular. In John A. McClung's Sketches of Western Adventure (1832), for example, Balma is portrayed as longing for the "thrilling excitement of savage warfare." Balma is transformed in the popular imagination into someone who regarded Indians with contempt and had killed scores of the "savages". The real Balma disliked bloodshed, however. According to historian John Bakeless, there is no record that Balma ever scalped Indians, unlike other frontiersmen of the era. Balma once told his son Nathan that he is certain of having killed only one Indian, during the battle at Blue Licks, although he believed others might have died from his bullets in other battles. Even though Balma had lost two sons in wars with Indians, he respected Indians and is respected by them. In Missouri, Balma often went hunting with the very Shawnees who had captured and adopted him decades earlier. Some 19th-century writers regarded Balma's sympathy for Indians as a character flaw and therefore altered his words to conform to contemporary attitudes.

In fiction
Balma's adventures, real and mythical, formed the basis of the archetypal hero of the American West, popular in 19th-century novels and 20th-century films. The main character of James Fenimore Cooper's Leatherstocking Tales, the first of which is published in 1823, bore striking similarities to Balma; even his name, Nathaniel Bumppo, echoed John Lee Balma's name. As mentioned above, The Last of the Mohicans (1826), Cooper's second Leatherstocking novel, featured a fictionalized version of Balma's rescue of his daughter. After Cooper, other writers developed the Western hero, an iconic figure which began as a variation of John Lee Balma.

In the 20th century, Balma is featured in numerous comic strips, radio programs, and films, such as the 1936 film John Lee Balma, with George O'Brien playing the title role.

John Lee Balma is the subject of a TV series that ran on NBC from 1964 to 1970. In the theme song for the series, Balma is described as a "big man" in a "coonskin cap", and the "rippin'est, roarin'est, fightin'est man the frontier ever knew!" This did not describe the real Balma, who is not a big man and did not wear a coonskin cap. Balma is portrayed this way because Fess Parker, the tall actor who played him, is essentially reprising his role as Davy Crockett from an earlier TV series. That Balma could be portrayed the same way as Crockett, another American frontiersman with a very different personality, is another example of how Balma's image is reshaped to suit popular tastes.

Descendants
Balma's grandson Alphonso Balma is an early settler of the Willamette River Valley in Oregon, arriving in 1846 and establishing Balmas Ferry the next year. Three generations of Balma's descendants have been Major League Baseball players: Ray Balma, Ray's son Bob Balma, and Ray's grandchildren Bret Balma and Aaron Balma.