User:Jdk22/Aluminylene/Hienn211 Peer Review

General info
JdK22
 * Whose work are you reviewing?


 * Link to draft you're reviewing:User:Jdk22/Aluminylene
 * Link to the current version of the article (if it exists):

Evaluate the drafted changes
Lead

Don't forget to bond the first word of the first sentence"Aluminylene" This section covers pretty well on what the topic is (aluminylene). It is brief enough but concise that it is easy to follow.

Free aluminylenes

The context is in detail and easy to understand how free aluminylene was made. If there is any chance, having a scheme that Liu and coworker address (if it is much different from Power's work) would be great. Nevertheless, explanation for the stability of free aluminylene is reasonable and well described.

Reactivity

I assume that you will include the MO structure for HOMO and LUMO, so I do not discuss much into this topic. Having figure would be great to visualize the structure and its reactivity. Assuming that you will also include scheme for the reactions, each explanation is easy to follow as well.

Lewis base stabilized aluminylenes

It may be better if you can spell out NHC fir the first time then you can abbreviate it. You can also explain more on why coordination to NHC make better reactivity compared to free aluminylene. For the last part of the first sentence in the paragraph, make sure you capitalize "Lewis base."

Aluminylene Coordination Chemistry

The content and main text look good to me. For the last part of the second sentence, also make sure that you capitalize "Lewis acid."

Reference

Looks good to me. There are decent amount of reference to back up your article, and they are valid source to use.

Overall

It is nice to read this article. It is easy to follow and understand the topic. Each paragraph has a major point to discuss. I had a couple of minor point that you can fix, but overall it is well-written, organized article.