User:Jengod/As They Were

As They Were is a 1982 collection of essays by M.F.K. Fisher, including several tales about her childhood in Whittier, California. As They Were (along with Long Ago in France and Sister Age) was one of the books she wrote at Last House in Glen Ellen, California. Fisher was a "revered" food writer, but this volume almost entirely avoids the topic on which she built her reputation, which some reviewers found disappointing. In As They Were, Fisher recalls visits to the Mission Inn in Riverside, stays at Swiss inns, kitchens in Provence in which she cooked, hotels and restaurants she patronized in Aix and Arles, and journeys by sea. Library Journal said the book was filled with "her usual delightful prose" and recommended it for purchase by libraries with a "sophisticated clientele." Several of the pieces had previously been published in magazines such as The New Yorker and The Atlantic Monthly.

The writer Carolyn See, reviewing for the Los Angeles Times, said the book made her feel uneasy: "All that good-life business: What if a good cafe au lait doesn't make a good life?...one notices M.F.K. speaking serenely of 'my husband,' an all-purpose costume that has been cut to fit several men." See's overall impression was of narcissism and hedonism and, yet, as she continues reading Fisher's writing, "The heart melts. M.F.K. God loves you." Lawrence W. Markert thought the book was a simply a worthy detour from edible subject matter to the similar genre of travel writing. Fred Smock thought "She does not travel, strictly speaking; she takes up residence, and so is privileged to see, hear and taste a life fuller than any tourist." Amanda Heller found that one chapter could be seen at least three ways: as reflection on "housekeeeping in the South of France, a metaphorical reflection on the moral texture of Provençal life, or an ode to paradise lost."