User:Jiawei Lu/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Hero (2002 film)

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
Hero is considered one of the representative Wuxia film after millennium. Plus the director of this film Zhang Yimo had gained his reputation from his work in the 80s. Hero is also an award-winning film at international film festivals which promote Chinese martial arts to the Western.

Evaluate the article
This lead has a clear introduction about this film. But the plot section is taking up relatively too much portion. Further adjustment can be done to compact the content. The interpretation and evaluation of the film are covered in the Critical response section, but most of them are excerpts from the film industry personnel and media in the West, especially North America. In addition, the criticism of the film being influenced by the director's political stance in the text does not account for the referential group and representatives of the object of questioning, so that readers do not have a conpreshensive understanding of the context.