User:Jktab/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Musakhan

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose to evaluate this article because it presents a prominent Arabic dish that is widely appreciated across the Levant. My preliminary impression of it was that it's very brief - it presents a good overview of the dish but does not dive deeply into its history or its cultural significance.

Evaluate the article
Lead Section: the article includes an introductory sentence that concisely and clearly describes its topic. It does not include a description of the article's major sections. It includes information not present in the remainder of the article but it's not overly detailed.

Content: the content is relevant to the topic, up-to-date. An area for improvement is adding some missing content on its history, cultural significance, regional variations...etc. It presents a dish from a historically underrepresented region.

Tone and Balance: the article is given from a neutral point of view. It is inclusive of all majority and minority groups that enjoy musakhan. It does not attempt to persuade the reader in favor of a particular position.

Sources and references: almost all the facts are backed up by reliable sources (one sentence is missing a source). The sources are thorough and current, written by a diverse spectrum of authors. Checked a few links and they worked.

Talk page: found some discussion on a previous insertion of a word-for-word recipe that was unnecessary (subsequently removed). It is part of the WikiProjects of Food and Drink, Palestine, and Jordan. It is rated stub class.