User:Jkudlick/XfD log/Archive

December 2014

 * 1) Articles for deletion/Instrument of Degradation: AfD; notified  12:25, December 29, 2014 (UTC)
 * 2) * Reason: Article has had two CSD tags removed, one for no content by the creator with minimal content added and one for duplicate content by a third party stating a redirect was possible. A PROD tag was also removed by a third party stating the topic was probably notable. The idea of an instrument of degradation is a general concept of a document stating that someone is removed from a particular position of honor or honorable society (thus not particularly notable, though certain degradations may be), yet the only example and source provided are the same example and source provided in Order of the Garter. A redirect would not be appropriate at this point because the only main space article that links to the page is also the only place this article could plausibly be redirected. Adding a clarifying statement to the Garter article would satisfy any need to provide additional information and still satisfy WP:NOT.
 * 3) ** Withdrawn As nominator and article creator have come to an agreement to alter and expand the scope of the article.
 * 4) Articles for deletion/FK Milutinac Zemun: AfD; notified  04:44, December 31, 2014 (UTC)
 * 5) * Reason: No evidence of notability, as the club appears to be only a year or two old. Being named for a famous footballer does not make the club notable.

January 2015

 * 1) Articles for deletion/FK Trudbenik Beograd: AfD; notified  05:39, January 3, 2015 (UTC)
 * 2) * Reason: CSD tag removed, then replaced by the same editor who removed it, then removed by an editor claiming the club participated in the 2010–11 Kup Srbije (Serbian Cup), thus meeting WP:FOOTYN. However, the club did not participate in that tournament, nor can I find any information that it ever competed in that cup or its predecessors. Absent any further information, the club fails FOOTYN.
 * 3) Articles for deletion/Sean Davis (soccer): AfD; notified  02:02, January 14, 2015 (UTC)
 * 4) * Reason: Contested PROD. Concern was Fails WP:GNG and WP:NFOOTBALL. PROD was contested by an editor without leaving an edit summary.

September 2015

 * 1) Articles for deletion/Malaysia v Saudi Arabia (2018 FIFA World Cup qualifying): AfD; notified  15:38, September 10, 2015 (UTC)
 * 2) * Reason: An abandoned match, regardless of the reason, is not in and of itself a notable occurrence. The match deserves mention in the AFC Second Round qualifying article and could deserve mention in the articles for the national teams of Malaysia and Saudi Arabia, but not a standalone article.

November 2015

 * 1) Articles for deletion/AFC Ann Arbor: AfD; notified  16:14, November 3, 2015
 * 2) * Reason: Club has not played in the national cup and is not in a WP:FPL, thus fails WP:FOOTYN. Club has not garnered significant coverage to meet requirements of WP:N.
 * 3) Articles for deletion/Grand Rapids FC: AfD; notified  16:16, November 3, 2015
 * 4) * Reason: Club has not played in the national cup and is not in a WP:FPL, thus fails WP:FOOTYN. Club has not garnered significant coverage to meet requirements of WP:N.
 * 5) Articles for deletion/Oakland United FC: AfD; notified  16:16, November 3, 2015
 * 6) * Reason: Club has not played in the national cup and is not in a WP:FPL, thus fails WP:FOOTYN. Club has not garnered significant coverage to meet requirements of WP:N.
 * 7) Articles for deletion/Spartans Futbol Club: AfD; notified  16:17, November 3, 2015
 * 8) * Reason: Club has not played in the national cup and is not in a WP:FPL, thus fails WP:FOOTYN. Club has not garnered significant coverage to meet requirements of WP:N.
 * 9) Articles for deletion/Real San Jose: AfD; notified  16:17, November 3, 2015
 * 10) * Reason: Club has not played in the national cup and is not in a WP:FPL, thus fails WP:FOOTYN. Club has not garnered significant coverage to meet requirements of WP:N.
 * 11) Articles for deletion/San Francisco Stompers FC: AfD; notified  16:17, November 3, 2015
 * 12) * Reason: Club has not played in the national cup and is not in a WP:FPL, thus fails WP:FOOTYN. Club has not garnered significant coverage to meet requirements of WP:N.
 * 13) Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion/User:TheShadowCrow/sandbox (3rd nomination): MfD; notified  14:51, November 7, 2015
 * 14) * Reason: This userpage is very large (~512KB) and is full of old drafts which have not been worked on in quite some time. broke out many of the drafts during the first MfD, but  restored them on two occasions, specifically  and, though his last constructive edit to the drafts was on , before his reversions of Technical 13's efforts, and his last overall edit was on May 10, 2014.
 * Long story short, WP:STALEDRAFT.

December 2015

 * 1) Articles for deletion/Transportation inequality in the United States: AfD; notified  03:26, December 6, 2015
 * 2) * Reason: Article appears to be a part of a class project. I recommend userfying the article back to with an admonition about original research. Also recommend that Wikimedia Foundation remind Kent State University of article guidelines.

January 2016

 * 1) Articles for deletion/International Academy for Genealogical and Heraldic Studies: AfD; notified  15:38, January 26, 2016
 * 2) * Reason: PROD removed. Original concern was "This is a bogus organisation. It purports to have high ideals but is using a stolen coat of arms arms. The arms they are using belong to Sir Alasdair Workman MacRobert, 2nd Baronet (1912–1938) - see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MacRobert_baronets . Although the baronetcy is extinct, this organisation has no authority to usurp the arms. The arms contain a Baronet's badge, something no organisation, in the whole of history was ever awarded." The usurped arms have been removed from the article, but the organization still fails WP:ORG and WP:GNG.

February 2016

 * 1) Articles for deletion/Xemi: AfD; notified  21:10, February 23, 2016
 * 2) * Reason: Prod removed following discussion at Talk:Xemi. Original concern was that the subject fails WP:NFOOTY and WP:GNG. Concern remains valid.

March 2016

 * 1) Articles for deletion/List of international goals scored by Luís Figo: AfD; notified  14:22, March 17, 2016
 * 2) * Reason: Non-notable list – fails WP:GNG for insufficient significant coverage, and also fails precedent that lists of international goals are automatically notable only for footballers who are/were their country's top scorer; when Figo retired, he was still only the second-highest scorer for Portugal.
 * Also see precedent at Articles for deletion/List of international goals scored by João Vieira Pinto and Articles for deletion/List of international goals scored by Gonzalo Higuaín.

August 2016

 * 1) Articles for deletion/Glossary of Australian Scouting terms: AfD; notified  12:22, August 25, 2016
 * 2) * Reason: Per very brief discussion, this is considered a non-notable topic. I'd prefer to see any truly notable terms merged into Scouts Australia than have this deleted outright.

October 2016

 * 1) Articles for deletion/Messi Goals Career: AfD; notified  05:40, October 27, 2016
 * 2) * Reason: Regardless of how notable a footballer is, a list of league goals is not notable (WP:NOTSTATS). While Wikipedia does have lists of goals scored, those are goals scored in international completion by footballers who are or were the top scorer for their nation. Anything worth keeping from this list can be merged into Lionel Messi.

January 2017

 * 1) Articles for deletion/List of international goals scored by Robert Lewandowski: AfD; Notified  01:45, January 24, 2017
 * 2) * Reason: Current consensus at WP:FOOTY is that stand-alone lists of international goals are only appropriate for footballers who are or were at some time the top scorer for their nation. Lewandowski is presently the third-highest scorer for Poland, thus this list is not yet notable.
 * 3) Templates for discussion/Log/2017 January 25: TfD; Notified 00:11, January 25, 2017
 * 4) * Reason: This template serves no encyclopedic purpose other than to duplicate the efforts of WP:DELSORT and CAT:AFD. The "series of AFDs" are linked by the mere fact that they are multi-national and/or multi-event sporting events. This template clutters the AFDs onto which it is transcluded. See WP:NENAN and WP:CLNT
 * TL;DR - This template is completely unnecessary.

October 2020

 * 1) Categories for discussion/Log/2020 October 30; CfD; Notified  02:42, October 30, 2020 (UTC); Notified  03:08, 30 October 2020 (UTC)
 * 2) * Reason: Fails WP:OCAWARD, which requires the award be a defining characteristic of the notable person. No one is notable simply for earning the rank of Eagle Scout.

November 2021

 * Sheikh Russel Smirity U-15 Gold Cup: nominated at AfD; notified 21:33, 16 November 2021 (UTC)
 * 1) * Reason: Invitational youth football tournament in its first year with very little coverage outside of standard match reports. Fails WP:GNG as well as any topical notability guidelines such as WP:SPORTSEVENT.

July 2022

 * Category:Africa Women Cup of Nations: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:Women's Africa Cup of Nations 18:24, 8 July 2022 (UTC)
 * 1) * Reason: per the successful RM discussion at Talk:Women's Africa Cup of Nations
 * Category:Africa Women Cup of Nations tournaments: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:Women's Africa Cup of Nations tournaments 19:00, 10 July 2022 (UTC)
 * 1) * Reason: per successful RM at Talk:Women%27s Africa Cup of Nations
 * Category:Africa Women Cup of Nations qualification: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:Women's Africa Cup of Nations qualification 19:02, 10 July 2022 (UTC)
 * 1) * Reason: per successful RM at Talk:Women's Africa Cup of Nations
 * Category:Africa Women Cup of Nations squads: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:Women's Africa Cup of Nation's squads 19:03, 10 July 2022 (UTC)
 * 1) * Reason: per successful RM at Talk:Women%27s Africa Cup of Nations

December 2023

 * Future FIFA Club World Cup (China): nominated at RfD; Target: 2025 FIFA Club World Cup (notified); notified 18:54, 17 December 2023 (UTC)
 * 1) * Reason: The 2025 edition will be held in the United States, not China. This is an extremely unlikely title to be looked up. The few articles that link here can easily be pointed to 2025 FIFA Club World Cup.
 * 2025–26 UEFA Women’s Nations League: nominated at AfD; notified 16:23, 26 December 2023 (UTC)
 * 1) * Reason: WP:TOOSOON – The article can be recreated once there is more official information.
 * 2025–26: nominated at RfD; Target: 2025–26 UEFA Women’s Nations League (notified); notified 16:50, 26 December 2023 (UTC)
 * 1) * Reason: Implausible redirect - there is a link to this refirect from 2024–25 Biathlon World Cup, so I'm pretty sure that anyone clicking this link from that article is not looking for the 2025–26 UEFA Women’s Nations League.