User:Johnsondeh/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
History of anthropology  Two-spirit

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because the class I am in is an Anthropological Theory class and the instructions said to choose an article related to the class.

I chose the two-spirit article because it relates to the topic of my project paper for the semester and I saw that it still has things that could be added to it.

Evaluate the article
I found the history of anthropology article to be well rounded and organized. The only shortcoming I can find is mentioned in one of the latest talk sections where someone points out that the article has a very Western focus and only small sections dedicated to the history of Anthropology in other areas of the world. Overall, the information is sound, well written, and sufficiently sourced.

Two-Spirit Article

Lead Section:

The lead section of the article is strong, it is short and accurately wraps up the general history of and current discourse around the term "two-spirit."

Content:

Content was good and very informative. Could use a little more in the history and anthropological accounts

Tone & Balance:

The overall tone is good, the topic is very controversial and it seems that the article does a good job at representing most of the different opinions.

Sources and References:

The sources are reliable and provide well-rounded information.

Images are a bit generic and could be improved.

Overall Impression:

Very close to being done, could just use a bit more information and better, more relevant photos.