User:Juliammanning/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
WikiProject Internet culture

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this WikiProject because it is current and interesting to find more information on a culture that is so vastly used everyday. My first impression on the page was that it was organized quite well, however there is little actual content describing what internet culture is or consists of.

Evaluate the article
The internet culture WikiProject does not have a good lead section. It's lead section has one sentence describing what the page is, but other than that it doesn't tell the reader what internet culture actually is. The content of the page is mostly made up of self promotion of contributors, along with some statistics of "quality internet culture articles" that seem to just be the opinions of the contributors. The page does have good organization, making it easy for viewers to digest the information on the page. They contributors do attribute any information on the page, my properly citing. There is not much media on the page, other than a few emojis, which are placed in a way that makes sense and doesn't distract from the content. The talk page of this WikiProject is mostly compiled of contributors disputing their recently deleted, inappropriate contributions to the page, accompanied by an odd internet troll.

Overall, the page has good potential and a good foundation to start. However, it could use more useful content about the topic.