User:JuneBug522/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Affleck Castle

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose Affleck Castle because of my personal interest in Scottish castles and medieval architecture. Affleck Castle was also of personal interest because of the lack of information surrounding the structure. My preliminary impression of the article was that there was a lack of history and information surrounding the architecture and history of the building, yet it is almost a complete structure.

Evaluate the article
This article is clearly and concisely written, with reliable sources. However, there is little to no introduction on the topic, as well as a lack of information beyond that of the basic structure of the castle. There is also little to no elaboration on the structure with images and/or construction documentation. The only picture of the building is obscured behind trees, preventing readers to get an accurate depiction of the architecture. This article could be improved with the addition of more sources, images, and background, as well as providing readers with other sections beyond that of "history" and "structure". Overall, it is an underdeveloped article with a lack of information on the structure. However, what is in the article is fairly decent.