User:Kalebn24/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Bilbo's rain frog

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
(Briefly explain why you chose it, why it matters, and what your preliminary impression of it was.)

I chose to write about this specific species as I thought it had a clever and intriguing name. After looking at the article, I found that it was relatively limited and there was a decent bit I could critique about it. It matters as it is a distinct species of amphibian and it is important to have accurate and current findings on as many species of animal as possible.

Evaluate the article
Lead Section

The opening sentence does a good job of introducing the reader to the topic of the Bilbo's Rain Frog. The lead does not include an overview of the sections of the article and goes into too much detail about the naming of the species.

Content

All of the content is relevant to the species and it was last edited in 2021 using relevant and recent information. All the information regarding the frog is relevant but limited in quantity. More information would help improve the quality of this article.

Tone and Balance

The tone and balance is appropriate as it is only documenting the known facts of a particular species of South African frog.

Sources and References

All the source links are working, accurate, recent, and credible. With that said, there is much more research that has been conducted and could have been included in this particular article to better round out and improve the overall quality of content provided.

Organization and Writing Quality

The organization is correct and the writing is free of any grammatical errors and is written in a professional manner.

Images and Media

While there is only one image, it adheres to Wikipedia's copyright rules and improves the overall experience for the reader by providing visual context on the species.

Talk Page Discussion

There are not any ongoing conversations in the talk page. One editor posed a question but it was never addressed. The article is rated as a C-Class article and is ranked as Low-Importance. It is part of WikiProject Amphibians and Reptiles.

Overall Impressions

The article does a good job of providing a general overview of the Bilbo's Rain Frog. The article could be improved by providing additional information such as what natural predators the frog has. I would say this article is underdeveloped as it does contain useful and introductory information about the frog, a lot of important information is also left out.