User:Karinlama/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
I am evaluating the article Beer

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because I like beer.

Evaluate the article
Lead

The lead is very informative. It explains the process of making beer and some interesting facts are also mentioned to make the paragraph more interesting.

Content

The article has everything one needs to know about beer.

Tone and balance

I think the article is balanced. In the article, it's mentioned that beer has both pros and cons. A neutral tone is maintained.

Sources and references

Ref 5 is from a book by Max Nelson about the history of beer in Ancient Europe.

Ref 28 is from a webpage from the Lifescience website.

Organization and writing quality

I think the writing quality is formal. The article is very well organized.

Images and media

There are sixteen images. The image of Beore 'beer' is under public domain.The image of Egyptian wooden model of beer making in ancient is under GNU Free Documentation License.The sixteenth-century brewery image is under public domain . The image of the hope cone is underGNU Free Documentation License .The image of Annual beer consumption per capita by country is under GNU Free Documentation License. The image of a dark lager is under the public domain. The rest of the images are under a free use license.

Talk page discussion

There are two talk page discussion. One of them is about adding reference to a statement and the other is about the image representing the beer culture of Cameroon.

Overall impressions

Overall, I find this article very interesting as the article has so much information to offer. From the origin of beer to the chemicals present in beer, everything is discussed in the article.

Navigation menu

 * Karinlama
 * You have a new Talk page message
 * Alert (1)
 * Notices (4)
 * Talk
 * Sandbox
 * Preferences
 * Beta
 * Watchlist
 * Contributions
 * Log out


 * User page
 * Talk


 * Read
 * Edit
 * View history
 * WikiLove




 * Main page
 * Contents
 * Current events
 * Random article
 * About Wikipedia
 * Contact us
 * Donate


 * Help
 * Learn to edit
 * Community portal
 * Recent changes
 * Upload file


 * What links here
 * Related changes
 * User contributions
 * User logs
 * Mute this user
 * View user groups
 * Special pages
 * Permanent link
 * Page information


 * Download as PDF
 * Printable version