User:Katiejill127/Chézy formula/Tina W Raad Peer Review

General info

 * Whose work are you reviewing?

katiejill127


 * Link to draft you're reviewing
 * User:Katiejill127/Chézy formula


 * Link to the current version of the article (if it exists)
 * Formula - Chézy formula
 * Biography - Antoine de Chézy

Evaluate the drafted changes
Hi Kate,

Thank you for thoroughly laying out your plan for the content you provided. You remained neutral, made relevant additions and provided much needed citations to multiple articles.

As someone who knows nothing of this formula and is terrible with math, I appreciate that your article was clear and easy to follow.

The page on Antoine de Chézy in your sandbox didn’t have actual references for source #1 and #4. It also had 5 references. The published article you had already edited has 4 complete references. I’m guessing that is something to do with the lack of resources on the original page that you were working with and not an oversight on your part.

Your additions are much needed for the almost non existent and unsourced Chézy article. Wish I was of more help for the engineering component of the article. All I can say is well done.

-Tina